Views in the last 30 days: 91
Estimated read time: 12 minute(s)
🔍 1️⃣ Purpose of Clause 6.2
Clause 6.2 ensures fair labor practices by requiring the Contractor to comply with local wage rates and labor conditions. It helps:
✅ Maintain compliance with local labor laws
✅ Avoid exploitation of labor
✅ Promote fair competition among Contractors
✅ Reduce risk of industrial disputes
This clause also protects the Employer from reputational and legal risks associated with non-compliant labor practices.
🕰️ Historical Context & Update (1999 ➡️ 2017)
- In the 1999 Edition, the clause simply required the Contractor to adhere to rates and conditions “not lower than” those established locally or generally observed.
- The 2017 Edition evolved this by explicitly stating compliance must be with applicable Laws, not just industry norms. This shift shows a stronger alignment with legal compliance frameworks and corporate social responsibility trends.
🧩 2️⃣ Breakdown of Clause 6.2
🟥 1999 Edition Text:
“The Contractor shall pay rates of wages, and observe conditions of labour, which are not lower than those established for the trade or industry where the work is carried out. If no established rates or conditions are applicable, the Contractor shall pay rates of wages and observe conditions which are not lower than the general level of wages and conditions observed locally by employers whose trade or industry is similar to that of the Contractor.”
🟩 2017 Edition Text:
“The Contractor shall pay rates of wages, and observe conditions of labour, which comply with all applicable Laws and are not lower than those established for the trade or industry where the work is carried out. If no established rates or conditions are applicable, the Contractor shall pay rates of wages and observe conditions which are not lower than the general level of wages and conditions observed locally by employers whose trade or industry is similar to that of the Contractor.”
🔑 Key Differences:
| Aspect | 1999 Edition | 2017 Edition |
|---|---|---|
| Reference to Law | Implied compliance | Explicit requirement to comply with applicable Laws |
| Scope of Wages & Conditions | Industry-based | Law-based + industry-based |
⚖️ 3️⃣ Key Interpretations and Implications
📌 Obligations:
- Contractor must benchmark wage levels and working conditions against legal and industry standards.
- Ignorance of legal wage/labour regulations is not an excuse in 2017.
🚨 Risks:
- Non-compliance may lead to:
- Legal penalties
- Project delays due to strikes or workforce unrest
- Termination under default clauses (e.g., Clause 15.2)
✅ Benefits:
- Encourages ethical labor practices
- Reduces the risk of project disruption due to labor grievances
🔗 4️⃣ Cross-Referencing with Other Clauses
You might be thinking, “Okay, Clause 6.2 says pay fair wages… got it. But how does that actually tie in with the rest of the contract?” Great question! In FIDIC, clauses don’t live in isolation—they’re part of a web of obligations. So let’s explore how Clause 6.2 interacts with its contractual cousins.
🧑⚖️ Clause 1.13 [Compliance with Laws] – The Foundational Anchor
This clause is the legal heartbeat of the contract. It says that both the Employer and Contractor must follow all applicable laws, not just pick and choose the convenient ones. When you combine this with Clause 6.2, it’s crystal clear:
✅ It’s not enough to just follow industry norms or traditional practices—you must comply with wage legislation, labor codes, and any statutory updates during the project lifecycle.
So if minimum wages go up mid-project, the Contractor can’t argue “but this is what we’ve always paid.” Clause 1.13 + 6.2 shuts that door.
⚖️ Clause 6.4 [Labour Laws] – Reinforcement and Extension
This one’s like the big sibling of Clause 6.2. While 6.2 is about rates and conditions, 6.4 goes wider—it pulls in the full spectrum of labor legislation:
- 📋 Working hours
- 🧪 Health inspections
- 🛠️ Safety standards
- 🩺 Welfare provisions
Together, 6.2 and 6.4 form a powerful duo—one zooms in on pay and working conditions, the other zooms out to cover the entire labor law landscape.
🛠️ Clause 13.6 [Adjustments for Changes in Laws] – Your Financial Safety Net
Let’s say the government enacts a sudden labor reform during your project—new safety requirements, longer leave entitlements, or, yes, higher wages.
Without Clause 13.6, the Contractor could be stuck footing the bill. But with it?
📌 The Contractor can claim for additional Cost or time if those changes were unforeseeable at tender.
This clause becomes especially important in the 2017 Edition, which aligns wage obligations more tightly with legal mandates under 6.2. So if laws change → clause 13.6 becomes your go-to.
📢 Clause 20.2 [Claims] – How You Ask for What You’re Owed
Let’s say you’re a Contractor and local laws just mandated a significant wage hike.
Here’s your playbook:
- Identify the issue under Clause 6.2 (wages affected).
- Confirm legal impact under Clause 1.13 (law compliance).
- Justify cost/time claim using Clause 13.6.
- File it properly using Clause 20.2.
Without this full-stack approach, your claim could be invalid—or worse, time-barred.
👮♂️ Clause 15.2 [Termination by Employer] – The Serious Consequence
If a Contractor persistently violates labor laws or fails to pay workers in line with Clause 6.2, this isn’t just a slap on the wrist. Under Clause 15.2(c) in many FIDIC contracts, this can be deemed a default—and yes, the Employer can terminate.
🚨 So it’s not just about compliance for compliance’s sake. Clause 6.2 can trigger much bigger consequences if ignored.
🧾 BONUS LINK: Clause 4.8 [Health and Safety]
Even though it’s technically outside the “wages” realm, Clause 4.8 is still a key neighbor. Fair wages often go hand-in-hand with good working conditions. If wage standards are being flouted, you’ll often see safety and welfare problems as well. And under Clause 4.8, the Contractor is on the hook for keeping people safe.
🔄 Final Thought:
Think of Clause 6.2 as the entry point. It’s the “you must pay fair wages” clause. But it’s backed up, supported, and enforced through:
- ⚖️ Legal obligation (1.13)
- 🧑🏭 Labor law compliance (6.4)
- 💸 Financial adjustment route (13.6)
- 📜 Claims mechanism (20.2)
- ❌ Potential termination (15.2)
- 🛡️ Health & safety (4.8)
🤔 5️⃣ What-If Scenarios
Scenario 1: Wage Hike Introduced by Local Government Mid-Project
- Under 1999: Contractor may struggle to claim additional costs unless covered under Clause 13.7.
- Under 2017: Contractor can invoke Sub-Clause 13.6 for cost adjustments due to changes in Laws, including wage laws.
Scenario 2: Contractor Pays Below-Minimum Wages
- Both editions: Risk of breach.
- Under 2017: More severe, as “compliance with applicable Laws” is expressly mandated.
✍️ 6️⃣ Suggestions for Clarity and Improvement
While Clause 6.2 [Rates of Wages and Conditions of Labour] is relatively concise, its simplicity can leave room for ambiguity or inconsistent interpretation—especially on complex international projects. Here’s how we can sharpen it up for better clarity and real-world application:
📌 1. Clarify What “Established” and “General Level” Mean
The 1999 wording refers to wages and conditions “not lower than those established for the trade or industry” or “not lower than the general level of wages and conditions observed locally.” This can be pretty vague.
🛠️ Improvement Suggestion:
Define what constitutes “established” rates—does this mean statutory minimum wages, collective bargaining agreements, or customary industry standards?
🔍 Example:
“…not lower than those prescribed by national labor regulations or, where no such law exists, by published collective agreements relevant to the local construction sector.”
This reduces subjective interpretation and provides a fallback framework for international or unfamiliar jurisdictions.
📌 2. Introduce a Requirement for Evidence of Compliance
The clause currently assumes compliance without demanding proof. That’s risky.
🛠️ Improvement Suggestion:
Add a requirement for the Contractor to periodically submit certified payroll records or wage payment logs to demonstrate compliance.
📄 Example Addition:
“The Contractor shall submit to the Engineer, on a monthly basis, certified wage registers and employment records evidencing compliance with this Sub-Clause.”
This strengthens enforceability and protects both the Employer and the workforce.
📌 3. Reference National and International Standards
To avoid conflicts between local practices and international norms (especially in cross-border projects), the clause could benefit from explicitly referencing standards.
🛠️ Improvement Suggestion:
Add a note allowing the Employer to specify compliance with international labor standards (e.g., ILO conventions), particularly in jurisdictions with weaker regulations.
🌍 Example Addition:
“Where local legislation does not specify minimum wage or employment conditions, the Contractor shall observe standards not lower than those set out in applicable ILO Conventions or the World Bank’s Environmental and Social Framework.”
This is particularly helpful on donor-funded projects where social safeguards are key.
📌 4. Define “Conditions of Labour” More Clearly
Right now, it’s unclear whether “conditions of labour” includes overtime pay, rest periods, leave entitlements, or insurance.
🛠️ Improvement Suggestion:
Expand the definition or include an annex that lists minimum labor condition expectations.
🧾 Example:
“Conditions of labour shall include, but not be limited to: hours of work, overtime entitlements, meal/rest breaks, leave (including sick and annual), safety provisions, and social security benefits.”
📌 5. Add a Trigger for Action When Standards Change
Labor laws and minimum wages evolve. A static obligation like in Clause 6.2 might not prompt timely updates.
🛠️ Improvement Suggestion:
Include an automatic review mechanism tied to official wage updates.
⏰ Example:
“The Contractor shall review and adjust, as necessary, the rates of wages and conditions of labour every 6 months, or upon notification of changes in applicable laws, whichever is earlier.”
This keeps compliance dynamic and up-to-date.
📌 6. Clarify Who Determines Disputes About Wages
Sometimes, the Contractor may claim they are complying—while the Employer believes otherwise. Who decides?
🛠️ Improvement Suggestion:
Add a clause referring such disputes to the Engineer for determination under Sub-Clause 3.5 (1999) or Sub-Clause 3.7 (2017).
🧑⚖️ Example:
“Any dispute regarding the interpretation of ‘established rates’ or ‘general levels’ under this Sub-Clause shall be determined by the Engineer in accordance with Sub-Clause 3.5/3.7.”
This ensures faster resolution and avoids escalation.
📌 7. Consider Regional Wage Variations
If the project spans multiple regions, wages may differ. A blanket statement like in Clause 6.2 might not capture this complexity.
🛠️ Improvement Suggestion:
Permit regional wage banding or zone-based wage matrices, where appropriate.
🗺️ Example:
“The Contractor shall pay wage rates commensurate with the applicable regional standards within the Project area, as defined in the Particular Conditions.”
🔄 Summary of Enhancement Opportunities
| Issue | Suggested Enhancement | Practical Benefit |
|---|---|---|
| Vague wage standard references | Define “established” and “general level” | Avoid disputes and ensure enforceability |
| No compliance proof required | Require payroll/wage records | Verify actual compliance |
| Weak in international context | Reference ILO/World Bank standards | Align with ESG and donor expectations |
| Undefined scope of “labour conditions” | Provide detailed list or annex | Ensure comprehensive protection |
| Static obligations | Add periodic review triggers | Respond to wage law changes |
| Dispute resolution gap | Link to Engineer’s decision powers | Fast-track wage-related disputes |
| Regional wage differences | Allow region-specific benchmarks | Better reflects on-ground realities |
✅ 7️⃣ Final Takeaways
- Clause 6.2 reinforces ethical and lawful labor standards.
- The 2017 Edition improves clarity by adding legal compliance obligations.
- Parties should cross-check wage obligations against Clause 6.4, Clause 13.6, and Clause 1.13.
- Employers are better protected in the 2017 version due to its stronger legal language.
✅ Clause 6.2 Compliance and Monitoring Checklist
| # | Checklist Item | Description | ✔ |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Applicable Wage Laws Identified | Confirm the Contractor has reviewed and documented all applicable local/national wage laws and industry standards. | ⬜ |
| 2 | Benchmark Established Rates | Compare proposed wage rates against published government rates, collective agreements, or prevailing industry practices. | ⬜ |
| 3 | Clarity on Labour Conditions | Ensure “labour conditions” include work hours, overtime, leave entitlements, and benefits. | ⬜ |
| 4 | Compliance with Clause 1.13 | Verify Contractor’s wage policies comply with the broader obligation to adhere to national laws under Clause 1.13. | ⬜ |
| 5 | Certified Payroll Records Submitted | Contractor submits certified monthly payroll records or wage logs as evidence of compliance. | ⬜ |
| 6 | Monitoring Mechanism in Place | Employer or Engineer has a system to periodically audit wage and labor condition compliance. | ⬜ |
| 7 | Response Plan for Legal Changes | Contractor has a plan to update wages and conditions if laws change (e.g., cost impact tracking, claims process readiness). | ⬜ |
| 8 | Dispute Resolution Path Identified | Disputes about wage levels or labor practices are referred to the Engineer per Clause 3.5/3.7. | ⬜ |
| 9 | Regional Wage Differences Considered | If applicable, regional variations in wage structures are reflected in labor deployment plans. | ⬜ |
| 10 | ILO or Donor Guidelines Incorporated | If the project is donor-funded, confirm compliance with ILO standards or financing institution requirements. | ⬜ |
📩 Letter 1: Notification of Non-Compliance with Labour Wage Standards (from Engineer to Contractor)
Subject: Notification of Non-Compliance – Clause 6.2 [Rates of Wages and Conditions of Labour]
To: [Contractor’s Name]
Date: [Insert Date]
Contract No.: [Insert Contract Number]
Project: [Insert Project Title]
Dear [Contractor’s Representative],
We refer to our recent site observations and interviews conducted with site labour under your employment. It has come to our attention that certain wage rates currently being paid may fall below the minimum rates established under applicable labour laws and/or industry norms.
In accordance with Clause 6.2 of the Conditions of Contract, you are required to ensure that wage rates and conditions of labour comply with all applicable laws and are not lower than those established locally for the trade or industry.
You are requested to:
- Provide certified payroll documentation for all staff and labour employed on-site for the past two months;
- Confirm in writing your current wage structure and compliance with local regulations;
- Rectify any non-compliance with immediate effect and provide evidence of corrective actions taken.
Please treat this matter with urgency. Failure to address this issue may constitute a material breach of the Contract, potentially triggering remedies under Clause 15.2.
Yours faithfully,
[Engineer’s Name]
[Title]
[Engineer’s Company Name]
📩 Letter 2: Contractor’s Notification of Wage Law Change and Intention to Claim
Subject: Notification of Change in Labour Law – Intention to Claim under Clause 13.6 and 6.2
To: The Engineer
Date: [Insert Date]
Contract No.: [Insert Contract Number]
Project: [Insert Project Title]
Dear [Engineer’s Name],
We write to notify you of a recent amendment to the [Country/State] Labour Law [Law Number], which came into effect on [Effective Date], mandating an increase in the minimum wage for construction labour by [Percentage/Amount].
This change materially affects our obligations under Clause 6.2 of the Contract, which requires compliance with applicable wage regulations. In line with Clause 13.6 [Adjustments for Changes in Laws], we intend to submit a formal claim for additional cost incurred as a result of this legal change.
We are currently assessing the financial impact and shall submit a fully detailed claim in accordance with Sub-Clause 20.2 within the stipulated time.
Should you require any preliminary information or wish to meet for clarification, we remain at your disposal.
Yours sincerely,
[Contractor’s Representative Name]
[Position]
[Contractor’s Company Name]
📩 Letter 3: Confirmation of Compliance with Clause 6.2 (Routine Submission)
Subject: Monthly Declaration of Compliance – Clause 6.2 [Rates of Wages and Conditions of Labour]
To: The Engineer
Date: [Insert Date]
Contract No.: [Insert Contract Number]
Project: [Insert Project Title]
Dear [Engineer’s Name],
In accordance with Clause 6.2 of the Contract and as part of our commitment to fair labor practices, please find attached the certified payroll records and labour compliance statement for the period [Start Date] to [End Date].
We confirm that:
- All wages paid during this period were at or above the applicable statutory and industry minimum rates;
- Labour conditions provided (including working hours, rest breaks, and benefits) complied fully with the requirements of local legislation and Clause 6.2 of the Contract;
- No grievances or disputes were recorded during this period related to wages or labour conditions.
We remain committed to maintaining full compliance and transparency.
Yours faithfully,
[Contractor’s Representative Name]
[Position]
[Contractor’s Company Name]