Master FIDIC 19.2: Key to Force Majeure Clarity

General Overview

• Importance in Contracts: Clause 19.2 is vital for managing the effects of unforeseen events on contractual obligations. It provides a clear mechanism for communication and adjustment in response to Force Majeure events.
• Legal and Practical Implications: Legally, this clause sets out the obligations for notification and the limits of relief provided. Practically, it guides parties in managing their responsibilities during Force Majeure events.
• Global and Local Context: While the clause provides a global framework, its application can be influenced by local laws and the specific terms of the contract.

Detailed Explanation of Clause 19.2: Notice of Force Majeure in the FIDIC Yellow Book 1999

Clause 19.2 is a crucial component of the FIDIC Yellow Book 1999, detailing the protocol for notifying Force Majeure events and its implications on contract obligations. Let’s delve into its key components, process flow, applicability, and provide a general overview.

Key Components of Clause 19.2

1. Notification Requirement: The clause mandates that a party affected by Force Majeure must notify the other party of the event.
2. Content of the Notice: The notice must specify the obligations that are or will be prevented due to the Force Majeure.
3. Timeframe for Notification: The notification must be made within 14 days after the party becomes aware, or should have become aware, of the Force Majeure event.
4. Exemption from Performance: The party is excused from performing the specified obligations as long as the Force Majeure event prevents it.
5. Exclusion of Payment Obligations: The clause explicitly states that Force Majeure does not apply to the obligations of either party to make payments under the contract.

Process Flow of Clause 19.2

1. Identification of Force Majeure Event: Recognizing an event that potentially qualifies as Force Majeure.
2. Awareness of Impact: Understanding how this event impacts contractual obligations.
3. Preparation of Notice: Drafting a notice that clearly specifies the affected obligations.
4. Timely Notification: Sending the notice to the other party within the 14-day window.
5. Temporary Relief from Obligations: The affected party is relieved from performing the specified obligations during the Force Majeure period.
6. Continuation of Payment Obligations: Both parties must continue to fulfill any payment obligations, regardless of the Force Majeure.

Applicability of Clause 19.2

• When: This clause is applicable when a party is prevented from performing its contractual obligations due to a Force Majeure event.
• How: It applies through a formal notification process, where the affected party must clearly articulate the obligations impacted by the event.

General Overview

• Importance in Contracts: Clause 19.2 is vital for managing the effects of unforeseen events on contractual obligations. It provides a clear mechanism for communication and adjustment in response to Force Majeure events.
• Legal and Practical Implications: Legally, this clause sets out the obligations for notification and the limits of relief provided. Practically, it guides parties in managing their responsibilities during Force Majeure events.
• Global and Local Context: While the clause provides a global framework, its application can be influenced by local laws and the specific terms of the contract.

Understanding Clause 19.2: Notice of Force Majeure in the FIDIC Yellow Book 1999

Clause 19.2 in the FIDIC Yellow Book 1999 outlines the procedure for notifying a Force Majeure event and its implications on contractual obligations. This clause plays a pivotal role in managing Force Majeure situations within the framework of a construction contract.

1. Purpose and Implications of Clause 19.2

• Purpose: The primary purpose of Clause 19.2 is to establish a formal notification process for Force Majeure events. This ensures that both parties are timely informed and can adjust their plans and expectations accordingly.
• Implications: Once a Force Majeure notice is given, the affected party is excused from performing the specified obligations impacted by the event, for the duration of the Force Majeure.

2. Notification Process in Clause 19.2

• Timely Notice: The party affected by Force Majeure must notify the other party within 14 days of becoming aware of the event.
• Specifics in Notice: The notice must specify the obligations affected by the Force Majeure, providing clarity on the scope of impact.

3. Exemption from Performance

• Temporary Relief: The affected party is excused from performing the specified obligations as long as the Force Majeure event continues.
• Scope of Relief: The relief is limited to the obligations directly impacted by the Force Majeure event.

4. Limitations of Clause 19.2

• No Relief for Payment Obligations: Importantly, Clause 19.2 explicitly states that Force Majeure does not excuse either party from their payment obligations under the contract.

5. Expert Opinion

• Risk Management: Experts often emphasize the importance of timely and accurate notification under Clause 19.2. Delayed or vague notifications can lead to disputes and complicate contract management.
• Legal Considerations: Legal advisors typically stress the need to document the awareness of the Force Majeure event and the rationale for how it impacts specific obligations.

6. Practical Considerations

• Documentation: Maintaining thorough documentation of the Force Majeure event and its impacts is crucial for both parties.
• Communication: Clear and ongoing communication between the parties during a Force Majeure event is essential for effective contract management.

Interaction of Clause 19.2: Notice of Force Majeure with Other Clauses in the FIDIC Yellow Book 1999

Clause 19.2 interacts with several other clauses in the FIDIC Yellow Book 1999, creating a network of relationships that govern the management of Force Majeure events. Let’s explore these interactions with varied phrasings and detailed explanations.

Interaction with Clause 8: Commencement, Delays, and Suspension

1. Shared Effects: Clause 19.2’s notification of Force Majeure directly impacts Clause 8, which deals with project timelines.
2. Detailed Explanation: When a Force Majeure event is notified under Clause 19.2, it may lead to an extension of time for project completion as outlined in Clause 8. This interaction ensures that delays caused by unforeseen events are formally acknowledged and adjusted in the project schedule.

Interaction with Clause 20: Claims, Disputes, and Arbitration

1. Shared Effects: The notification process in Clause 19.2 can trigger Clause 20, particularly in dispute resolution.
2. Detailed Explanation: If there’s a disagreement over the validity of a Force Majeure claim or its impact on the contract, Clause 20 provides the mechanism for resolving such disputes. The initial notification under Clause 19.2 is often a critical piece of evidence in these proceedings.

Interaction with Clause 13: Variations and Adjustments

1. Shared Effects: Clause 19.2’s Force Majeure notice may necessitate contract variations as per Clause 13.
2. Detailed Explanation: In response to a Force Majeure event, there might be a need for contract variations or adjustments. Clause 13 comes into play here, providing a framework for implementing these changes, which could include cost adjustments due to the Force Majeure event.

Interaction with Clause 16: Suspension and Termination by Contractor

1. Shared Effects: Prolonged Force Majeure events notified under Clause 19.2 might lead to suspension or termination as per Clause 16.
2. Detailed Explanation: If a Force Majeure event extends for a considerable duration and significantly hampers project progress, the contractor might invoke Clause 16 to suspend or terminate the contract. The notification under Clause 19.2 serves as a foundational step in this process.

Interaction with Clause 14: Contract Price and Payment

1. Shared Effects: Despite a Force Majeure notice under Clause 19.2, payment obligations, as outlined in Clause 14, remain unaffected.
2. Detailed Explanation: Clause 19.2 explicitly states that Force Majeure does not excuse either party from payment obligations. Therefore, even during a Force Majeure event, the terms of Clause 14 regarding payments must still be adhered to.

Essential Factors in Implementing Clause 19.2: Notice of Force Majeure

When employing Clause 19.2 from the FIDIC Yellow Book 1999, it’s crucial to consider several key factors to ensure its effective implementation. These factors guide parties in appropriately managing Force Majeure events within the contractual framework.

1. Timely Notification

• Promptness: Ensure that the notice of the Force Majeure event is given within the specified 14-day period.
• Awareness: The party should be aware of when they became, or should have become, aware of the Force Majeure event to meet the notification timeline.

2. Detailed and Clear Notification

• Specificity: The notice must clearly specify which contractual obligations are affected by the Force Majeure event.
• Clarity: The description of the Force Majeure event should be clear and detailed to avoid ambiguity.

3. Documentation and Evidence

• Evidence of Impact: Collect and provide evidence that demonstrates how the Force Majeure event prevents the performance of specific obligations.
• Record Keeping: Maintain thorough documentation of all communications and evidence related to the Force Majeure event.

4. Understanding the Scope of Relief

• Performance Obligations: Recognize that the relief provided is specific to performance obligations and does not extend to payment obligations.
• Temporary Relief: Understand that the relief from performance is only for the duration that the Force Majeure event continues to prevent performance.

5. Legal and Contractual Compliance

• Alignment with Contract Terms: Ensure that the implementation of Clause 19.2 is in accordance with the terms and conditions of the contract.
• Compliance with Local Laws: The implementation should also be in line with relevant local laws and regulations.

6. Communication with Other Party

• Ongoing Dialogue: Maintain open and continuous communication with the other party throughout the duration of the Force Majeure event.
• Negotiation and Adjustment: Be prepared to negotiate and adjust other aspects of the contract as necessary, in response to the Force Majeure event.

7. Preparation for Post-Force Majeure Resumption

• Plan for Resumption: Develop a plan for how obligations will be resumed once the Force Majeure event ceases to prevent performance.
• Update and Inform: Keep the other party informed about plans and readiness for resuming normal contract obligations.

Process Flowchart for Implementing Clause 19.2

Detailed Explanation of the Process Flowchart for Implementing Clause 19.2

1. Start with Event Identification
   • Process Initiation: The process begins when a potential Force Majeure event occurs. This could be a natural disaster, political unrest, or any other significant event that might impact contractual obligations.
2. Assess the Impact on Contractual Obligations
   • Critical Assessment: The party affected by the event must assess its impact on their ability to fulfill contractual duties. This involves a thorough analysis of the event’s scope and potential effects on the project.
3. Decision Node: Determining Force Majeure
   • Key Decision Point: A crucial decision must be made: Does the event qualify as Force Majeure as per the contract’s definition?
   • Criteria Evaluation: This involves evaluating whether the event is beyond control, unforeseeable, unavoidable, and not attributable to the other party.
4. If Yes: Prepare and Send Force Majeure Notice
   • Notice Preparation: If the event is deemed Force Majeure, the next step is to prepare a formal notice. This notice must clearly specify which contractual obligations are affected and provide details about the event.
   • Timeliness: The notice must be sent within 14 days of recognizing the event as Force Majeure.
5. If No: Regular Contract Provisions Apply
   • Standard Procedures: If the event does not meet the Force Majeure criteria, standard contract provisions continue to apply. This means managing the event’s impact without the specific relief provided under Force Majeure.
6. Submit Notice to Other Party
   • Formal Communication: The notice is formally submitted to the other contractual party. This step is crucial for official documentation and initiating any subsequent contractual adjustments.
7. Temporary Relief from Specified Obligations
   • Relief Granted: Upon submitting the notice, the affected party is temporarily relieved from performing the specified obligations impacted by the Force Majeure event.
8. Continue Payment Obligations
   • Ongoing Financial Responsibilities: Despite the Force Majeure event, both parties must continue to fulfill any payment obligations under the contract. This aspect is explicitly stated in Clause 19.2.
9. Manage Contract During Force Majeure
   • Contract Administration: The final step involves managing the contract during the Force Majeure period. This includes ongoing communication, potential renegotiations, and adjustments to the project plan as necessary.

Flowchart: Clause 19.2 Interaction with Other Clauses

Detailed Explanation:

1. Force Majeure Event Identification: Starts with identifying a Force Majeure event.
2. Clause 19.2 Activation: Triggers Clause 19.2 for the notification process.
3. Interactions with Other Clauses:
   • Clause 8: Leads to adjustments in project timelines due to the Force Majeure event.
   • Clause 20: Invokes the dispute resolution process in case of disagreements related to the Force Majeure claim.
   • Clause 13: Necessitates contract variations or adjustments in response to the Force Majeure event.
   • Clause 16: Considers the possibility of suspension or termination of the contract due to prolonged Force Majeure.
   • Clause 14: Maintains the obligation for payment despite the Force Majeure event.
4. End Results: Each interaction leads to specific outcomes, ensuring the contract adapts to the Force Majeure event.

Sequence Diagram: Implementing Clause 19.2

Detailed Explanation:

1. Event Occurrence: The sequence begins with a Force Majeure event occurring.
2. Initial Notification: The Contractor notifies the Project Manager (PM) of the potential Force Majeure event.
3. Consultation for Assessment:
   • The PM consults with the Engineer to assess whether the event qualifies as Force Majeure under Clause 19.2.
   • The Engineer advises on the status, confirming or denying the event as Force Majeure.
4. Communication of Decision:
   • The PM communicates the decision back to the Contractor.
5. Preparation of Force Majeure Notice:
   • If the event is confirmed as Force Majeure, the Contractor prepares an official Force Majeure notice.
   • The PM reviews and approves the notice for completeness and accuracy.
6. Submission of Official Notice:
   • The Contractor submits the official Force Majeure notice to the PM.
7. Acknowledgment and Discussion of Adjustments:
   • The PM acknowledges the notice and discusses necessary adjustments to the contract with the Contractor.
8. Implementation of Adjustments:
   • The Contractor implements the agreed-upon adjustments to manage the impact of the Force Majeure event.
9. Monitoring and Reporting:
   • The PM, with the help of the Engineer, monitors the implementation and reports on the adjustments.
   • The Engineer provides ongoing assessments of the situation.
10. Continued Contract Management:

• The PM and the Contractor continue with the contract management, incorporating the adjustments and dealing with the ongoing Force Majeure situation.

Checklists

1. Checklist for Proficient Execution and Deployment of Clause 19.2

Step	Action Item	Details	Responsible Party
1	Identify Potential Force Majeure Events	Monitor for events that may qualify as Force Majeure under Clause 19.2	Contractor/Project Manager
2	Immediate Notification	Notify the other party promptly if a potential Force Majeure event occurs	Contractor
3	Documentation of Event	Collect and document evidence supporting the Force Majeure claim	Contractor
4	Assessment of Event	Assess the event against Clause 19.2 criteria	Engineer/Project Manager
5	Communication and Consultation	Discuss the event and its impacts with all stakeholders	Contractor/Project Manager
6	Prepare Force Majeure Notice	Draft a notice specifying affected obligations within 14 days	Contractor
7	Submit Force Majeure Notice	Officially submit the notice to the other party	Contractor
8	Monitor and Adjust Project Plan	Make necessary adjustments to the project timeline and budget	Contractor/Project Manager
9	Documentation and Reporting	Keep detailed records of all actions and adjustments made due to the Force Majeure event	Contractor

2. Checklist for Applying and Overseeing Clause 19.2

Step	Action Item	Details	Responsible Party
1	Clause Familiarization	Ensure all parties understand the terms of Clause 19.2	Contractor/Project Manager
2	Early Detection	Stay vigilant for signs of potential Force Majeure events	Contractor
3	Prompt Action	Act quickly to notify and document when an event occurs	Contractor
4	Legal Review	Consult legal advisors to confirm Force Majeure status	Project Manager
5	Stakeholder Engagement	Keep all stakeholders informed about the situation	Contractor/Project Manager
6	Review Contractual Implications	Understand how Clause 19.2 affects other contract clauses	Project Manager
7	Implement Changes	Apply the necessary changes to the project	Contractor
8	Monitor Compliance	Ensure all actions comply with the contract and local laws	Project Manager
9	Final Reporting	Document the entire process for future reference	Contractor

3. Checklist for Guiding and Monitoring the Execution of Clause 19.2

Step	Action Item	Details	Responsible Party
1	Event Identification	Recognize and confirm Force Majeure events	Contractor
2	Immediate Notification and Documentation	Notify other party and document the event details	Contractor
3	Evaluate Impact	Assess how the event impacts the project	Project Manager
4	Consultation with Experts	Seek expert advice on handling the event	Project Manager
5	Draft Force Majeure Notice	Prepare the notice specifying affected obligations	Contractor
6	Submit Official Notice	Send the notice to the other party	Contractor
7	Regular Updates	Provide ongoing updates to all parties	Contractor/Project Manager
8	Adjust Project Scope	Modify the project scope as necessary	Contractor/Project Manager
9	Legal and Contractual Adherence	Ensure all steps are in line with legal and contractual requirements	Project Manager
10	Comprehensive Closure Report	Create a detailed report post-event for record-keeping	Contractor

Sample Letters

Scenario 1: Notifying of a Force Majeure Event

Subject: Notification of Force Majeure Event Under Clause 19.2

Dear [Project Manager/Contractor’s Name],

I am writing to formally notify you of a Force Majeure event as defined under Clause 19.2 of our contract [Contract Number]. On [Date], [describe the Force Majeure event, e.g., a severe earthquake], occurred, which has significantly impacted our ability to carry out our contractual obligations.

As required by Clause 19.2, this letter serves as an official notification within 14 days of becoming aware of the event. The specific obligations affected by this event are [list the obligations]. We are currently taking all reasonable measures to mitigate its impact and will keep you updated on our progress.

We request your understanding and cooperation as we navigate through this challenging period. We will provide further details and discuss the necessary adjustments to our contractual obligations as soon as possible.

Sincerely, [Your Name] [Your Position] [Your Company]

---

Scenario 2: Confirming Receipt of Force Majeure Notification

Subject: Acknowledgment of Force Majeure Notification

Dear [Contractor’s Name],

We acknowledge the receipt of your notification dated [Date], regarding the Force Majeure event under Clause 19.2 of our contract [Contract Number]. We understand that the [describe the Force Majeure event] has impacted your ability to fulfill certain contractual obligations, specifically [list the obligations mentioned in the notification].

We appreciate your prompt notification and commitment to mitigating the impact of this event. We will review the situation and engage in discussions to determine the necessary adjustments to our contract terms.

Please keep us informed of any developments, and do not hesitate to reach out for any further discussions or clarifications.

Sincerely, [Your Name] [Your Position] [Your Company]

---

Scenario 3: Requesting Additional Information on Force Majeure Event

Subject: Request for Further Information on Force Majeure Event

Dear [Contractor’s Name],

We refer to your recent notification regarding a Force Majeure event under Clause 19.2 of our contract [Contract Number]. In order to fully assess the situation and its impact on our contractual obligations, we kindly request additional information.

Specifically, we would like more details on [list specific information needed, e.g., the nature of the event, estimated duration, affected obligations, mitigation measures]. This information is crucial for us to make informed decisions and to discuss potential adjustments to the contract.

We appreciate your cooperation in providing this information as soon as possible to facilitate a smooth resolution to this situation.

Sincerely, [Your Name] [Your Position] [Your Company]

FAQs: Clause 19.2 Notice of Force Majeure in FIDIC Yellow Book 1999

What is Clause 19.2 in the FIDIC Yellow Book 1999?

Clause 19.2 outlines the procedure for a party to notify the other of a Force Majeure event. It specifies how and when to communicate such events and the implications on contractual obligations.

When should a party notify the other of Force Majeure under Clause 19.2?

A party should notify the other within 14 days after becoming aware, or should have become aware, of the Force Majeure event.

What should be included in a Force Majeure notice under Clause 19.2?

The notice should specify the obligations affected by the Force Majeure event and provide details about the event itself.

Does Clause 19.2 provide relief from all contractual obligations?

No, Clause 19.2 provides relief from performance obligations affected by the Force Majeure event but explicitly excludes relief from payment obligations.

Can a party delay the notification of Force Majeure?

Delaying the notification beyond 14 days can lead to complications and may affect the party’s ability to claim relief under this clause.

---

Common Misunderstandings Associated with Clause 19.2

1. Any Delay is Acceptable: A common misconception is that notification can be delayed as long as the Force Majeure event is ongoing. However, the clause requires notification within 14 days of awareness.
2. All Obligations are Excused: Another misunderstanding is that all contractual obligations are excused under Force Majeure. Clause 19.2 specifically excludes payment obligations from this relief.
3. Informal Notification is Sufficient: Some parties may believe that informal communication or verbal notification is enough. However, formal written notification is required to comply with Clause 19.2.