Table of Contents
ToggleViews in the last 30 days: 98
Estimated read time: 12 minute(s)
Purpose of FIDIC Clause 3.4 Delegation by the Engineer
Clause 3.4 of FIDIC empowers the Engineer to hand over specific duties to trusted assistants, ensuring contract administration stays efficient, decisions get made fast, and both Employer and Contractor benefit from smoother project progress.
FIDIC Clause 3.4 provides the mechanism through which the Engineer can delegate specific duties and responsibilities to assistants. This delegation is crucial because it allows the Engineer to efficiently manage contract administration by spreading workload and enabling focused oversight.
For both the Employer and the Contractor, this delegation ensures streamlined project administration, quicker decision-making on-site, and continuous supervision, particularly for complex, large-scale projects.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who can the Engineer delegate duties to under Clause 3.4?
The Engineer can delegate duties to assistants or representatives, provided they are suitably qualified and the delegation is properly notified to the Contractor.
Does delegation mean the Engineer has no responsibility?
No, the Engineer remains responsible for the overall administration and must ensure that delegated tasks are performed correctly.
What happens if there is a dispute over a delegated instruction?
Disputes over delegated actions are still managed under the contract, and the Engineer must clarify or resolve any confusion. See Clause 3.7 (Determinations) for more on resolving such issues.
Where can I learn about related FIDIC clauses?
Check out these detailed guides:
- Delegation under Clause 3.2: Engineer may assign duties and delegate authority to assistants (e.g., resident engineers, inspectors) via written notice.
- When does delegation take effect? Only after both parties receive copies of the delegation notice.
- Requirements for assistants: Must be competent, fluent in contract language, and have clearly defined roles.
- Limit of authority: Assistants’ authority is strictly limited to the scope of the Engineerâs notice.
- Key restriction: Engineer cannot delegate the power to make contract determinations (see Clause 3.7).
- Delegation under Clause 3.4: Engineer can delegate tasks/authority by written notice, specifying each assistantâs role.
- Effectiveness: Delegation becomes valid only after the Engineer issues a notice and both parties receive it.
- Requirements: Assistants must have suitable qualifications, experience, and contract language proficiency.
- Authority to issue instructions: Strictly limited by the delegation notice.
- Dispute escalation: Contractor can challenge instructions; the Engineer must respond within 7 days or the assistantâs instruction stands.
- Introduced an explicit escalation process for disputing assistantâs instructions.
- Set a clear 7-day deadline for Engineerâs response to disputes.
These changes clarify the process and protect both parties from decision-making delays.
FAQs on Delegation by the Engineer
Where can I read more about delegation authority?
For details on the 1999 edition, see Clause 3.2 Delegation by the Engineer.
How are disputes resolved?
Disputes over assistant instructions are escalated to the Engineer (2017), who must respond within 7 days, or the instruction is confirmed. See Clause 3.7 for more.
Which roles cannot be delegated?
The Engineer cannot delegate contract determinations or other powers reserved by the contract (see Clause 3.7).
đ ď¸ Engineer
- Define authority and scope of each delegate clearly.
- Remain accountable for all acts of delegates.
đ§ Contractor
- Follow instructions from delegates within delegated authority.
- Escalate immediately if an instruction seems outside scope or inappropriate.
đ˘ Employer
- Benefits from efficient contract administration.
- Should ensure clarity in communication and approvals between Engineer & delegates.
-
Contractual determinations:
- 1999: See Clause 3.5
- 2017: See Clause 3.7
- Issuing a formal “Notice to Correct” (Clause 15.1).
đ Clause 3.5 (1999) / 3.7 (2017): Determinations
- Engineer must personally handle major contractual decisions.
- Delegation does not extend to these crucial determinations.
đ˘ Clause 15.1: Notice to Correct
- Only the Engineer can issue formal “Notice to Correct.”
- Delegated assistants cannot perform this critical action.
- An assistant tells the Contractor to change material specs.
- The Contractor suspects this exceeds the assistantâs delegated authority.
- The Contractor promptly notifies the Engineer.
- 2017 Edition: Engineer has 7 days to confirm, reverse, or adjust the instruction.
- If no response in 7 days, the instruction automatically standsâpotentially risking extra costs or disputes.
- An assistant instructs substantial extra work.
- Contractor complies without verifying the assistantâs authority.
- Later, itâs revealed the assistant exceeded their delegation scope.
- This sparks a disputeâwho pays?
- An assistant verbally instructs relocation of underground conduits.
- No written confirmation is given initially.
- With the revised Clause 3.4, the Contractor checks the delegation log.
- Contractor confirms in writing, requesting Engineerâs written confirmation.
- If Engineer fails to reply but acknowledges receipt, the instruction is deemed valid in 7 days. Documentation protects the Contractor.
1. Define “Assistants” Clearly
âAssistants shall include only professionally qualified persons with at least five (5) yearsâ relevant experience in works of comparable nature and complexity. The Engineer shall notify the Employer and Contractor of the professional credentials and CVs of all proposed assistants.â
2. Ensure Communication & Language Clarity
âIf any assistant is not fluent in the communication language defined under Sub-Clause 1.4, the Engineer shall provide competent interpreters on Site at all times during working hours.â
3. Protect Contractor Rights on Dubious Instructions
âThe Engineer shall, within two (2) working days of receiving a referral from the Contractor regarding an assistantâs instruction, acknowledge receipt and indicate whether further clarification is required. The Engineerâs silence beyond the 7-day period shall be deemed as a confirmation only if this initial acknowledgment was provided.â
Golden Principles Compliant Clause 3.4
- Assistantâs name
- Delegated powers (e.g., materials approval, site inspections)
- Effective and expiration dates
- Revocations
âThe Engineer may from time to time assign duties and delegate authority to assistants by giving a written notice to both Parties. This notice shall:
(a) Identify the assistant by name, qualification, and professional experience (minimum five (5) years in similar works);
(b) Specify the delegated duties and limits of authority;
(c) State the effective and (if applicable) expiration date of the delegation;
(d) Confirm that the assistant is fluent in the language defined in Sub-Clause 1.4 or that suitable translation services will be provided at all times during working hours.
The Contractor shall only act on instructions from such assistants to the extent explicitly stated in the Engineerâs written notice. If the Contractor disputes an instruction or Notice given by an assistant, it shall notify the Engineer within two (2) working days, who shall acknowledge the referral within two (2) additional working days. The Engineer shall respond within seven (7) days thereafter, either confirming, reversing, or varying the instruction.
A current register of all assistant delegations shall be maintained and updated by the Engineer and made accessible to both Parties upon request.â
- GP1: Engineerâs role remains central.
- GP2: Clear, documented, and auditable delegation for all Parties.
- GP3: No unfair risk shift to Contractor.
- GP4: Realistic, fair timeframes for instructions and clarifications.
- GP5: No restriction of dispute referral pathways (DAAB).
Engineer determines that certain duties or authority should be delegated for effective project management.
- Engineer selects assistants with proper technical qualifications.
- Must have relevant experience and fluency in the contract language.
- Engineer prepares a written notice stating assistantâs name, role, and scope of authority.
- Specifies limitationsâcritical duties (Clause 3.7 & 15.1) are excluded from delegation.
- Engineer sends the notice to both the Employer and Contractor.
- Delegation only takes effect after both receive the notice.
- Contractor reviews and adjusts communication accordingly.
- Recognizes assistants as authorized (within their delegated powers).
- Contractor objects in writing to Engineer.
- Engineer has 7 days to review and respond (confirm, reverse, or adjust the instruction).
- If no response in 7 days, assistantâs instruction stands by default.
Checklist 1: For the Engineer â Before Delegating Duties
Step | Action | Details |
---|---|---|
1 | Identify Potential Assistants | Ensure they are suitably qualified and fluent in the language of communication. |
2 | Define Scope of Delegation | Make clear what duties and responsibilities are being delegated. |
3 | Draft Delegation Letter | Create a written notice outlining the delegation, as required by Clause 3.2. |
4 | Notify Both Parties | Send copies of the delegation notice to both the Employer and the Contractor. |
Checklist 2: For the Contractor â Upon Receiving Delegation Notice
Step | Action | Details |
---|---|---|
1 | Review Delegation Scope | Understand the extent and limitations of the delegated authority. |
2 | Check Assistantâs Qualifications | Ensure the assistant is competent in relevant areas, such as U.S. technical standards or environmental laws. |
3 | Update Project Team | Inform the relevant team members about the delegation. |
4 | Document Concerns | If any, prepare to question the determination or instruction of the assistant. |
Checklist 3: For Ongoing Monitoring and Compliance
Step | Action | Details |
---|---|---|
1 | Regular Updates | Both parties should keep each other informed about the progress of the delegated tasks. |
2 | Compliance Checks | Regularly review compliance with relevant standards and regulations, e.g., U.S. building codes. |
3 | Record-Keeping | Maintain comprehensive records of instructions, approvals, and determinations. |
4 | Review and Revoke | The Engineer may need to review the effectiveness of the delegation and revoke if necessary. |