Clause 3.3 Instructions of the Engineer – FIDIC Yellow Book [1999]

Interpretation of Clause 3.3 Instructions of the Engineer

1. Purpose

   The primary aim of Clause 3.3 is to clarify the framework within which the Engineer can issue instructions to the Contractor. It provides a system that ensures all instructions are in alignment with the Contract, and that they are only to be received from the Engineer or a delegated assistant.

   Implications

   1. Authority and Delegation: Only instructions from the Engineer or a properly delegated assistant are to be considered valid.
   2. Compliance: The Contractor is obliged to comply with these instructions, which must be issued in writing.
   3. Variations: If an instruction results in a variation, then Clause 13 comes into play, which deals with variations and adjustments.

   Expert Opinion

   This clause is pivotal because it sets the stage for how changes and directives will be managed. In projects with complex engineering standards, such as those following ANSI or ASME in the U.S., instructions from the Engineer are often crucial to maintain compliance with local regulations.

   

   Trending

   Employer’s Financial Arrangements – Clause 2.4 of FIDIC Yellow Book

   Interaction with Other Clauses

   • Clause 13 [Variations and Adjustments]: Any instruction that alters the scope or execution of work would invoke this clause.
   • Clause 3.2 [Delegation by the Engineer]: The Engineer’s authority to delegate is critical as the Contractor is instructed to heed directives from such delegated individuals.

   Main Points to Keep in Mind

   1. Always verify the source of the instruction to ensure it’s coming from a duly authorized individual.
   2. Maintain records of all written instructions for compliance and potential audits.
   3. Be proactive in assessing whether an instruction may trigger a variation under Clause 13.

Real-World Instances and Case Studies

Case Study 1: Infrastructure Project in the U.S.

In a highway development project in the United States, the Engineer needed to issue a set of instructions to address unexpected soil conditions. The Contractor was initially reluctant to proceed, fearing that the changes would incur additional costs. However, because Clause 3.3 stipulates that the Contractor must comply with such instructions, the Contractor proceeded. Later, through Clause 13, adjustments were made to the contract to cover the extra costs.

Key Takeaway: Following the proper channel of instructions can lead to fair adjustments and keeps the project aligned with regulations like the U.S. Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) standards.

Case Study 2: Commercial Building Construction

A Contractor working on a commercial building in San Francisco received an instruction from an assistant to the Engineer, who had been delegated the authority under Clause 3.2. The instruction was to use a specific type of fire-resistant material to comply with California’s strict fire codes. Following Clause 3.3, the Contractor complied and was later able to justify the additional costs through Clause 13.

Key Takeaway: Delegation by the Engineer can streamline processes, especially when specific local regulations, such as California’s Fire Code, need quick compliance.

Case Study 3: Environmental Compliance in a Utility Project

In a water treatment plant project in the U.S., the Engineer issued a set of instructions that involved changes to the wastewater treatment process. This was to ensure compliance with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) guidelines. Clause 3.3 made it clear that these instructions had to be followed to the letter, ensuring that the project met stringent environmental standards.

Key Takeaway: Instructions from the Engineer can be vital for aligning the project with environmental regulations, and Clause 3.3 ensures there’s a framework for such compliance.

Sample Letters:

Letter 1: Request for Clarification on Engineer’s Instructions

---

Dear [Engineer’s Name],

I hope this message finds you well. We recently received your instructions dated [Date], regarding [Instruction Summary]. Before we proceed, we would like to seek some clarification to ensure that we comply fully with your instructions, as mandated under Clause 3.3.

Could you please elaborate on [Specific Point needing clarification]?

We look forward to your prompt response.

Best regards,
[Your Name]
[Your Position]

---

Letter 2: Acknowledgment of Receipt of Engineer’s Instructions

---

Dear [Engineer’s Name],

We are writing to acknowledge the receipt of your instructions dated [Date], concerning [Instruction Summary]. As per Clause 3.3, we understand the importance of complying with these instructions and will take the necessary steps to implement them immediately.

Please confirm that we can proceed as planned.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Position]

---

Letter 3: Notification of Completion Following Engineer’s Instructions

---

Dear [Engineer’s Name],

I am pleased to inform you that we have successfully completed the tasks as per your instructions dated [Date]. All procedures were carried out in accordance with Clause 3.3 of our contract.

We kindly request you to inspect the completed works at your earliest convenience and provide any further instructions if necessary.

Best regards,
[Your Name]
[Your Position]

---

Letter 4: Expression of Concern Regarding Engineer’s Instructions

---

Dear [Engineer’s Name],

We received your instructions dated [Date] regarding [Instruction Summary]. While we understand that under Clause 3.3, we are obliged to follow your directions, we have some concerns that these instructions may [describe concern, e.g., delay the project, increase costs, etc.].

Could we perhaps discuss this matter further at your earliest convenience?

Best regards,
[Your Name]
[Your Position]

Flowcharts & Checklists:

Detailed Explanation of the Flowchart

1. Start: Need for Instruction Identified
   • The process begins when the Engineer identifies a need to issue an instruction, either for executing specific works or remedying defects.
2. Engineer Issues Written Instruction
   • The Engineer formulates and issues the necessary instruction in writing to the Contractor.
3. Decision: Is Instruction a Variation?
   • A decision point to determine if the instruction leads to a Variation in the scope of work.
4. Yes: Apply Clause 13 for Variations
   • If the instruction constitutes a Variation, Clause 13 (Variations and Adjustments) is applied to manage this change.
5. No: Contractor Complies with Instruction
   • If the instruction does not constitute a Variation, the Contractor proceeds to comply with the instruction as issued.
6. Manage Variation Process (If Applicable)
   • The process of managing the Variation, as per Clause 13, involves adjusting the contract terms, scope, and possibly the price.
7. Work Execution or Defect Remediation
   • The Contractor executes the work or remedies the defects as per the Engineer’s instruction.
8. Variation Implemented in Project (If Applicable)
   • If a Variation was involved, it is implemented into the project.
9. Project Continues as per Contract
   • The project continues following the contract terms, incorporating either the executed instruction or the implemented Variation.

Flowchart 1: Functionality and Implications of [Clause 3.3]

Flowchart 1: Functionality and Implications of [Clause 3.3]

1. Start: Engineer Issues an Instruction
   • The process begins with the Engineer issuing an instruction. This is a directive or order given by the Engineer to the Contractor regarding the execution of the works.
2. Contractor Receives Instruction
   • Upon receiving the instruction, the Contractor reviews and assesses its implications. This step is crucial as the Contractor needs to understand the nature and scope of the instruction to implement it effectively.
3. Does it lead to additional costs or delays?
   • The Contractor evaluates whether the instruction leads to any additional costs or causes delays in the project. This is a decision point in the flowchart.
4. Yes Path: Contractor gives notice of claim
   • If the instruction results in additional costs or delays, the Contractor is entitled to give notice of a claim. This is a formal communication to the Engineer, indicating that the Contractor seeks compensation or an extension of time due to the implications of the instruction.
5. No Path: Contractor proceeds as instructed
   • If the instruction does not lead to any additional costs or delays, the Contractor proceeds to implement the instruction without any claims.
6. Engineer has 42 days to respond
   • Once the Contractor gives notice of a claim, the Engineer has a set period (typically 42 days in many FIDIC contracts) to respond to the claim. During this time, the Engineer reviews the claim, assesses its validity, and determines the appropriate course of action.
7. Engineer’s Response
   • The Engineer provides a formal response to the Contractor’s claim. This is another decision point in the flowchart.
8. Agrees with Contractor: Adjustments made to Contract
   • If the Engineer agrees with the Contractor’s claim, adjustments are made to the Contract. This could involve compensating the Contractor for additional costs or granting an extension of time for the project.
9. Disagrees with Contractor: Instruction remains unchanged
   • If the Engineer disagrees with the Contractor’s claim, the instruction remains unchanged. The Contractor is then expected to proceed with the original instruction without any adjustments to the Contract.

The flowchart provides a visual representation of the process and implications when the Engineer issues an instruction under [Clause 3.3]. It highlights the potential paths the Contractor can take based on the nature of the instruction and the Engineer’s subsequent responses.

Flowchart 2: Execution of [Clause 3.3] and its Associations with Other Clauses

Flowchart 2: Execution of [Clause 3.3] and its Associations with Other Clauses

1. Start: Commencement of Project
   • The flowchart begins with the initiation or commencement of a construction project. This is the point at which the contract becomes active, and the parties involved start their respective roles.
2. Engineer’s Role Established
   • Early in the project, the role and responsibilities of the Engineer are established. This sets the foundation for how the Engineer will interact with the Contractor and the Employer throughout the project’s duration.
3. Engineer Issues Instructions under Clause 3.3
   • As the project progresses, the Engineer may need to issue instructions to the Contractor. These instructions can pertain to various aspects of the work, from technical details to changes in scope.
4. Associated with Clause 3.2: Engineer’s Representative
   • This association indicates that the Engineer’s instructions might sometimes be conveyed through an Engineer’s Representative. Clause 3.2 typically outlines the duties and authority of this representative.
5. Associated with Clause 4.4: Subcontracting
   • Some instructions from the Engineer might relate to subcontracting parts of the work. Clause 4.4 generally deals with the conditions under which the Contractor can subcontract parts of the work and the Engineer’s role in approving or overseeing these subcontracts.
6. Associated with Clause 13.3: Variations
   • The Engineer’s instructions might sometimes lead to variations in the work, either adding, modifying, or omitting certain parts. Clause 13.3 typically outlines how these variations are to be handled, priced, and incorporated into the contract.
7. Associated with Clause 7.5: Remedial Work
   • If the Engineer finds that some work is not in accordance with the contract, they might instruct its removal or correction. Clause 7.5 usually deals with the procedures and implications of such instructions.
8. End: Project Completion
   • The flowchart culminates in the completion of the project. By this point, all instructions, associations, and implications would have been addressed, and the project would be finalized.

Detailed Explanation of the Sequence Diagram

1. Engineer Issues Written Instructions
   • The Engineer initiates the process by issuing written instructions to the Contractor for the execution of works or remedying defects.
2. Contractor Acknowledges Receipt
   • The Contractor acknowledges the receipt of these instructions, confirming their understanding.
3. Request for Clarification (If Needed)
   • If the Contractor needs clarification on the instructions, they request it from the Engineer.
4. Engineer Provides Clarification
   • The Engineer responds with the necessary clarification to ensure the Contractor fully understands the instructions.
5. Contractor Implements Instructions
   • The Contractor proceeds to implement the instructions as directed.
6. Engineer Monitors Implementation
   • The Engineer monitors and evaluates the implementation of their instructions to ensure compliance and quality.
7. Contractor Reports Completion
   • Upon completing the task, the Contractor reports the completion to the Engineer.
8. Engineer Informs Employer
   • The Engineer informs the Employer about the instruction implementation and any significant outcomes.
9. Employer Provides Feedback
   • The Employer, upon reviewing the information, provides feedback or additional directives to the Engineer.
10. Relaying Employer’s Feedback
    • The Engineer relays the Employer’s feedback to the Contractor.
11. Adjustments as per Feedback
    • The Contractor makes any necessary adjustments to the work based on the Employer’s feedback.
12. Engineer Approves Final Work
    • The Engineer reviews and approves the final work after adjustments.
13. Contractor Submits Work for Final Approval
    • The Contractor submits the completed work to the Employer for final approval.
14. Employer Confirms Project Completion
    • The Employer confirms the completion of the project or the specific task, marking the end of the sequence.

Checklist

Checklist 1: For the Contractor – Steps to Take Upon Receiving Engineer’s Instructions

Step No.	Action Item	Responsible Party	Date Completed
1	Confirm receipt of Engineer’s Instructions	Contractor
2	Review Instructions for clarity	Contractor
3	Seek clarification if needed	Contractor
4	Plan implementation	Project Manager
5	Execute as per instructions	Field Supervisor
6	Document all actions taken	Contractor
7	Notify Engineer upon completion	Contractor

Checklist 2: For the Engineer – Issuing Instructions

Step No.	Action Item	Responsible Party	Date Completed
1	Identify need for issuing instructions	Engineer
2	Draft the instructions	Engineer
3	Ensure alignment with Clause 3.3	Engineer
4	Send instructions to the Contractor	Engineer
5	Confirm receipt by Contractor	Engineer
6	Provide clarifications if requested	Engineer
7	Inspect implementation and provide feedback	Engineer

Checklist 3: Compliance and Monitoring of Instructions

Step No.	Action Item	Responsible Party	Date Completed
1	Review Engineer’s instructions for compliance requirements	Legal Team
2	Monitor the implementation of instructions	Compliance Team
3	Document any deviations and report to Engineer	Compliance Team
4	Verify completion status with Engineer	Project Manager
5	Archive all relevant documentation	Admin

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What types of instructions can the Engineer issue under Clause 3.3?
   • The Engineer can issue any instructions that are necessary for the execution of the Works and the remedying of any defects, as long as they are in accordance with the Contract.
2. Can the Contractor ignore an instruction if it’s not in writing?
   • No, the Contractor is obligated to comply with instructions from the Engineer or a delegated assistant, whether or not they are in writing.
3. Can the Engineer’s assistant also issue instructions?
   • Yes, but only if the assistant has been delegated the appropriate authority under the contract.
4. What should the Contractor do if an instruction is unclear?
   • The Contractor should seek clarification from the Engineer to ensure proper execution.
5. What happens if the Engineer’s instruction constitutes a Variation?
   • If an instruction leads to a Variation, then Clause 13 related to Variations and Adjustments will apply.

Common Misunderstandings

1. Any Instruction is a Variation: Some may misunderstand that any instruction from the Engineer automatically constitutes a Variation. This is not the case; only those that result in changes to the agreed Works are Variations.
2. Verbal Instructions are Non-binding: While it’s best practice to have instructions in writing for clarity and documentation, verbal instructions are still binding if they come from an appropriately delegated authority.
3. No Right to Question: Some Contractors might think they have no right to question an instruction. However, if an instruction is unclear or seems to conflict with the Contract, it should be clarified with the Engineer.
4. Immediate Compliance Required: Some may believe that the Contractor must immediately comply with all instructions. While timely compliance is important, the Contractor may need time to mobilize resources or make plans, especially for complex instructions.