Table of Contents
ToggleViews in the last 30 days: 52
Estimated read time: 18 minute(s)
“Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material” 🆚 “Employer-Supplied Materials and Employer’s Equipment”
Unlock the Secrets of FIDIC: Clause 4.20 (1999) vs Clause 2.6 (2017) – Your Interactive Guide!
Hey there, contract enthusiast! Ever wondered how FIDIC clauses evolve to make construction projects smoother? Let’s dive into the Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Materials with this fun, interactive breakdown. We’ll keep it educational but amp up the excitement – think tabs, timelines, and even a quick quiz to test your knowledge. Ready to level up your FIDIC game?
For more on the basics, check out our deep dive into Contractor’s General Obligations (Clause 4.1).
Why This Clause Rocks (And Why It Exists)
Picture this: The Employer hands over pricey gear or materials to keep things rolling. This clause spells out who does what, when, and how – all to dodge drama on site. It’s about sharing goodies while pinning down risks. In 1999, it was basic; by 2017, it got a serious upgrade for clarity. Excited? Let’s compare!
Clause 4.20 – FIDIC Yellow Book 1999
“The Employer shall make the Employer’s Equipment (if any) available for the use of the Contractor in the execution of the Works in accordance with the details, arrangements and prices stated in the Contract. Unless otherwise stated in the Contract, the Employer shall supply, free of charge, the ‘free-issue materials’ (if any) in accordance with the Employer’s Requirements. The Contractor shall be responsible for each item of Employer’s Equipment and free-issue material from the time it is taken over by the Contractor until it is returned to the Employer.”
This one’s straightforward, like a no-frills toolbox. It lets the Employer provide stuff like specialized gadgets, but once you (the Contractor) grab it, it’s all on you. No detailed rules on checks or insurance – that’s where disputes can sneak in.
- Empowers Employers to supply sensitive or high-value items directly.
- Shifts full risk to the Contractor right after handover.
- Keeps quiet on handover rituals, inspections, or what-ifs like damage.
Pro Tip: Simplicity is cool, but it can bite back in real projects. For risk-handling vibes, peek at Contractor’s Care of the Works (Clause 17.2).
Clause 2.6 – FIDIC Yellow Book 2017
“The Employer shall provide to the Contractor, free of charge, the Employer-Supplied Materials and/or Employer’s Equipment (if any), in accordance with the details, arrangements and timing stated in the Contract Data. The Contractor shall be responsible for each item of Employer-Supplied Materials and Employer’s Equipment from the time it is delivered to, or taken over by, the Contractor until it is returned to the Employer, or otherwise disposed of, in accordance with the Engineer’s instructions. The Contractor shall provide appropriate storage and protection and shall use them only for the purposes of the Contract. The Contractor shall notify the Engineer immediately if any item is lost, damaged, defective, or not as stated in the Contract Data.”
Now we’re talking upgrades! Moved to the Employer’s section for logic, with extra layers of detail to keep everyone happy and disputes at bay.
- Uses Contract Data for crystal-clear docs on what, when, and how.
- Mandates instant alerts to the Engineer for any hiccups like damage.
- Spells out storage and protection duties – no more guessing games.
- Covers return or disposal per Engineer’s say-so.
Pro Tip: This version’s all about prevention. Dive into the Engineer’s world with Clause 3.1 – Engineer’s Duties and Authority.
1999 vs 2017: The Ultimate Comparison
| Aspect | 1999 Edition (Clause 4.20) | 2017 Edition (Clause 2.6) |
|---|---|---|
| Location in Contract | Under Contractor’s responsibilities | Under Employer’s responsibilities – more logical! |
| Documentation | Basic contract details | Detailed via Contract Data for timing and arrangements |
| Responsibility Transfer | Upon takeover by Contractor | Upon delivery/takeover, with storage & protection rules |
| Notifications | None specified | Immediate alert for loss, damage, or defects |
| End of Use | Return to Employer | Return or dispose per Engineer’s instructions |
| Risk Management | Ambiguous, potential for disputes | Clear protocols to minimize finger-pointing |
This evolution shows FIDIC getting smarter about real-world headaches. For broader principles, explore FIDIC Golden Principles.
The Evolution Timeline: From Simple to Sophisticated
1999: The Foundation
Basic handover rules kick in. Employer supplies, Contractor takes the wheel – but with gaps that could spark issues.
2017: The Upgrade
Clarity reigns! Adds notifications, storage duties, and Engineer-guided disposal. Disputes? Not on this watch.
Test Your FIDIC Smarts: Quick Quiz!
Question: In the 2017 edition, what must the Contractor do if materials are damaged?
Practical Tips to Nail This Clause
- Snap photos and log conditions on handover – evidence is your best friend!
- Set up secure storage zones to meet 2017’s protection rules.
- Flag issues ASAP to the Engineer – it’s not just smart, it’s required.
- Review Contract Data like your project depends on it (because it does!).
For legal compliance tips, head over to Clause 1.13 – Compliance with Laws.
Breaking Down FIDIC: Clause 4.20 (1999) vs Clause 2.6 (2017) – Let’s Decode It!
Alright, FIDIC fans, let’s get real about what these clauses actually say. We’ll unpack the words, spotlight the sneaky omissions, and see how the 2017 version steps up its game. Think of this as your backstage pass to contract clarity – no legalese overload, just straight talk with a dash of excitement. Ready to dissect? Jump in!
For a refresher on the big picture, check out our guide to Contractor’s General Obligations (Clause 4.1).
1999 Edition – Clause 4.20: The Essentials
The clause is brief but significant. It confirms that once Employer-supplied goods are in the Contractor’s hands, so is the risk.
What it says:
- Employer may supply equipment or materials.
- Contractor is liable once possession is taken.
- No mention of inspection or notice procedures.
What it doesn’t say is often more important:
- How to document delivery?
- What if items are damaged upon arrival?
- Who insures these?
This lack of guidance opens doors to disputes and misunderstandings. It’s like handing over keys without checking the car first – risky business! For more on handling those risks, explore Contractor’s Care of the Works (Clause 17.2).
2017 Edition – Clause 2.6: A Smarter Approach
Here’s where structure meets practicality.
Key inclusions:
- Reference to Contract Data for clarity.
- Storage and handling must meet specified standards.
- Mandatory immediate notification of any defects or loss.
- Use only for project-specific needs.
- Return/disposal as per Engineer’s instructions.
By adding these mechanisms, the clause reduces risk and strengthens project controls. It’s like upgrading from a basic lock to a smart security system – way more reliable! Curious about the Engineer’s role? Dive into Clause 3.1 – Engineer’s Duties and Authority.
1999 vs 2017: Spot the Differences
| Aspect | 1999 Edition | 2017 Edition |
|---|---|---|
| Length & Detail | Brief, focuses on basics | Structured with practical additions |
| Risk Transfer | Immediate upon possession | Same, but with safeguards like notifications |
| Omissions | No guidance on docs, damage, insurance | Covers storage, notifications, usage limits |
| Dispute Potential | High due to ambiguities | Lower with clear mechanisms |
This upgrade makes 2017 a game-changer for smoother projects. For overarching rules, check FIDIC Golden Principles.
Test Your Breakdown Knowledge: Quick Quiz!
Question: What’s missing in the 1999 clause that could spark disputes?
Pro Tips for Navigating These Clauses
- Always inspect and document Employer-supplied items on arrival – photos and logs save the day!
- In 2017 projects, prioritize quick notifications to keep risks low.
- Clarify insurance early; don’t let ambiguities bite later.
For compliance vibes, head to Clause 1.13 – Compliance with Laws.
Digging Deeper: Key Interpretations and Implications of FIDIC Clause 4.20 (1999) vs 2.6 (2017)
Hey FIDIC explorers, ready to geek out on the real-world vibes of these clauses? We’re talking implications that can make or break your project – from sneaky risks to clever cross-links with other clauses. I’ll keep it chatty and fun, but packed with insights so even newbies get the full picture. Let’s unpack the critical points and see how everything connects!
For a solid foundation, peek at our breakdown of Contractor’s General Obligations (Clause 4.1).
Critical Points Across Both Editions
These gems apply to both versions, but 2017 amps up the protection. Let’s spotlight the Contractor’s Responsibilities – because hey, knowledge is power on site!
- Safe custody and handling from moment of receipt.
- Use only for the Works.
- Cover losses/damage unless promptly reported (2017 only).
Bottom line? The Contractor’s on the hook once those items hit your hands. But in 2017, that quick report can be your lifesaver. For more on handling gear, check Clause 4.17 (Contractor’s Equipment) to see the differences.
Risk of Ambiguity (1999)
The 1999 edition leaves some doors wide open for trouble – no wonder 2017 stepped in to fix it!
- No built-in mechanism for condition assessment.
- No guidance on what happens if something is missing or defective.
- 2017 fixes this by introducing formal notification and documentation.
Imagine getting faulty materials with no playbook – chaos! The upgrade in 2017 adds those notifications to slam the door on disputes. If claims pop up from delays, explore Clause 20 (Claims) for the full scoop.
Cross-Referencing with Other Clauses – How They Interact
Clauses don’t live in isolation – they team up! Here’s how Clause 4.20/2.6 plays nice with others, making your contract a well-oiled machine.
| Clause | Role |
|---|---|
| Clause 18/19 (Insurance) | 2017 better connects these obligations with insurance responsibilities. Dive deeper into Clause 18 Insurance for coverage tips. |
| Clause 4.17 (Contractor’s Equipment) | Helps distinguish between Employer-supplied and Contractor-owned items. Check out our full analysis on Clause 4.17. |
| Clause 20 (Claims) | If Employer delays supply, Contractor can claim time or money — especially in 2017. Explore the claims process in Clause 20. |
| Clause 13.5 (Daywork) | Relevance if Employer materials are used in work measured on a daywork basis. Get the lowdown on Clause 13.5. |
Seeing these connections? It’s like a FIDIC puzzle coming together. For balanced contracts overall, don’t miss FIDIC Golden Principles.
Test Your Implications IQ: Quick Quiz!
Question: In 2017, what can save the Contractor from covering losses?
Pro Tips for Mastering Implications
- Always cross-check with insurance clauses – link up those responsibilities early!
- Document everything in 1999 projects to plug those ambiguity gaps.
- Use 2017’s notifications as your secret weapon against claims.
For legal alignment, swing by Clause 1.13 – Compliance with Laws.
What If Scenarios – Let’s Make It Real with FIDIC Clause 4.20 (1999) vs 2.6 (2017)
Okay, FIDIC adventurers, time to bring these clauses to life! What if things go sideways on your project? We’ll role-play some real-world headaches, comparing how 1999 and 2017 handle the drama. Then, we’ll dish out smart suggestions to level up your contracts. It’s like a choose-your-own-adventure, but with less risk and more wisdom. Buckle up – this could save your next gig!
For context on the basics, swing by our take on Contractor’s General Obligations (Clause 4.1).
Scenario 1: Theft of Employer-Supplied Generator
- 1999: Contractor pays — no formal review or exception process.
- 2017: If the Contractor reported inadequate delivery conditions, they may shift liability.
Picture this: A shiny generator vanishes overnight. In 1999, you’re probably footing the bill with no backup plan. But 2017? That early report could flip the script. For theft risks, check Contractor’s Care of the Works (Clause 17.2).
Scenario 2: Supplied Steel is Warped
- 1999: No formal notice system — could be blamed later.
- 2017: Must notify the Engineer immediately — paper trail protects the Contractor.
Oops, the steel arrives bent like a pretzel. 1999 might leave you arguing blame, but 2017’s quick alert creates a shield. Engineer in the mix? Dive into Clause 3.1 – Engineer’s Duties and Authority.
Scenario 3: Delivery Delay by Employer
- Both editions allow Contractor to seek EOT and/or Cost.
- Clause 20 would be the route for claims.
Employer’s late on delivery – now what? Both versions let you claim extensions or cash, via Clause 20. Smart move for delays? Explore Clause 20 (Claims).
Suggestions for Clarity and Improvement
For 1999 Users
- Add procedures for inspection and delivery notes.
- Clarify insurance responsibilities.
- Use Particular Conditions to expand documentation obligations.
Stuck with 1999? Beef it up with custom tweaks to avoid those “what if” nightmares. Insurance unclear? Head to Clause 18 Insurance.
For 2017 Users
- Ensure Contract Data clearly lists each supplied item.
- Add a template for delivery reports and notices.
- Specify turnaround time for Engineer responses.
Rocking 2017? Fine-tune with these extras for bulletproof projects. For golden rules, see FIDIC Golden Principles.
| Scenario Quick Compare | 1999 | 2017 |
|---|---|---|
| Theft of Generator | Contractor pays – no exceptions. | Report conditions to shift liability. |
| Warped Steel | No notice – blame game later. | Immediate notify – protected by paper trail. |
| Delivery Delay | Claim EOT/Cost via Clause 20. | Same, with stronger controls. |
Test Your Scenario Savvy: Quick Quiz!
Question: In Scenario 2 (Warped Steel), what protects the Contractor in 2017?
Pro Tips to Dodge These Scenarios
- Prep delivery checklists – snap pics, note issues on the spot!
- Build in insurance chats early – cover your bases.
- For delays, log everything and claim fast via Clause 20.
For compliance in chaos, check Clause 1.13 – Compliance with Laws.
Your Ultimate Checklist for Employer-Supplied Materials & Equipment in FIDIC – Clause 4.20 (1999) vs 2.6 (2017)
Hey there, FIDIC checklist champ! Ready to tackle Employer-supplied stuff like a pro? This isn’t just a boring list – it’s your roadmap to avoiding headaches on site. We’ll break it down by phase, comparing 1999 and 2017 editions, so you can spot the differences and stay ahead. Whether you’re prepping for delivery or wrapping up, these steps will keep things smooth. Let’s dive in and check those boxes!
For a quick refresher on the clauses, check out our deep dive into Clause 4.20/2.6.
Pre-Delivery Phase: Get Set Before the Goods Arrive
Start strong! These steps ensure everything’s lined up before the Employer drops off those materials or equipment. Think of it as your project warm-up.
| Task | Description | Applicable to |
|---|---|---|
| Define Items in Contract | Ensure all Employer-supplied materials/equipment are clearly listed in the Contract (1999) or Contract Data (2017). | Both |
| Specify Delivery Terms | Confirm who is responsible for transport, timing, and handover conditions. | Both |
| Clarify Storage Requirements | Check if the contract defines how the Contractor should store or secure these items. | 2017 (stronger), advisable for 1999 |
| Create Handover Protocol Template | Prepare a checklist or form for item condition, quantity, and packaging status on delivery. | Recommended for both |
| Confirm Insurance Responsibilities | Clarify in writing who insures the items during delivery and on-site. | Especially important in 1999 |
Pro tip: Nail these early to dodge surprises. For insurance deets, explore Clause 18 Insurance.
Delivery & Handover Phase: The Big Arrival Moment
Game time! When the goods show up, these checks keep everything accountable and protected.
| Task | Description | Applicable to |
|---|---|---|
| Sign-Off on Delivery Note | Have both parties sign delivery documentation noting item count, condition, and any visible defects. | Both |
| Photograph Delivered Goods | Take photos as evidence of condition at handover. | Both |
| Assign Storage Area | Allocate secure, weather-resistant space on-site for storage. | Mandatory in 2017 |
| Immediate Notification | Notify the Engineer immediately if items are missing, damaged, or defective. | Mandatory in 2017, best practice in 1999 |
| Label Clearly | Mark items as “Employer-Supplied” to avoid confusion with Contractor’s equipment. | Both |
Remember, pics or it didn’t happen! For Engineer notifications, see Clause 3.1 – Engineer’s Duties.
During Use: Keep Things Rolling Smoothly
On the job now – treat these items like gold to avoid any post-project drama.
| Task | Description | Applicable to |
|---|---|---|
| Log Usage | Keep a record of when and how items are used in the Works. | Both |
| Use Only for the Contract | Ensure items are not used on other projects or for unrelated work. | Both, emphasized in 2017 |
| Maintain & Protect | Keep items clean, covered, and protected from corrosion, theft, or environmental damage. | Both |
Stay vigilant – proper care pays off. For protection tips, check Clause 4.18 – Protection of the Environment.
Post-Use / Completion: Wrap It Up Right
Finish line! These final steps ensure a clean handover and no loose ends.
| Task | Description | Applicable to |
|---|---|---|
| Return Unused Items | Return any unused materials/equipment or dispose of them according to Engineer’s instructions. | Explicit in 2017 |
| Submit Return Report | Log all items returned, their condition, and who signed for them. | Both |
| Final Inspection | Jointly inspect returned items with the Employer’s team. | Both |
| Close-Out Documentation | Archive all delivery, usage, and return records for final audit or dispute resolution. | Both |
Archive like a boss – it could save you in audits. For disputes, explore Clause 20 (Claims).
Test Your Checklist Mastery: Quick Quiz!
Question: What’s mandatory in 2017 during delivery if items are defective?
Pro Tips to Supercharge Your Checklist
- Customize templates for your project – add digital signatures for speed!
- Schedule regular audits during use to catch issues early.
- Integrate with progress reports for seamless tracking.
For golden contract practices, don’t miss FIDIC Golden Principles.
Your FIDIC Letter Toolkit: Sample Letters for Clause 4.20 (1999) & Clause 2.6 (2017) – Ready to Copy & Customize!
Hey FIDIC letter wizards, ever stared at a blank page wondering how to nail that perfect notification? We’ve got you! These sample letters are your secret weapons for handling Employer-supplied materials like a boss. We’ll break them down with tabs for easy access, copy buttons for quick grabs, and even a quiz to test your skills. Whether it’s acknowledging receipt or flagging damage, these templates keep things professional and on-point. Let’s turn those clause headaches into smooth communications!
For more on the clauses themselves, check out our guide to Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Materials.
Sample Letter 1: Acknowledgment of Receipt of Employer-Supplied Materials
This one’s your smooth operator for confirming everything’s A-OK on arrival. Use it to build that paper trail early! For storage tips, see Clause 4.22 – Security of the Site.
Sample Letter 2: Notification of Damaged Employer-Supplied Material
Spot damage? This letter’s your shield – flag it fast and protect yourself. Engineer guidance needed? Check Clause 3.1 – Engineer’s Duties and Authority.
Sample Letter 3: Request for Clarification on Non-Delivery of Employer-Supplied Equipment
Delays hitting hard? This letter gets the ball rolling on claims. For the claims process, explore Clause 20 (Claims).
Test Your Letter Know-How: Quick Quiz!
Question: In Letter 2, what should you attach for proof?
Pro Tips for Using These Letters
- Customize placeholders with real details – make it your own!
- Always CC key players like the Employer’s Rep for transparency.
- Follow up if no response – keep that communication flowing.
For broader FIDIC wisdom, head to FIDIC Golden Principles.