Comprehensive Analysis of Clause 4.20: Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material

Interpretations of Clause 4.20

Summary of Clause 4.20

The Clause 4.20 in the FIDIC Yellow Book 1999 deals with the Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material. The Employer is responsible for making available any equipment specified in the Employer’s Requirements for the Contractor’s use in the execution of the Works. The Contractor is responsible for the equipment while it is being operated, driven, directed, or in possession or control of the Contractor’s Personnel. The Employer is also responsible for supplying “free-issue materials” in accordance with the details stated in the Employer’s Requirements. The Contractor must visually inspect these materials and notify the Engineer of any shortages, defects, or defaults. The Employer is responsible for rectifying any issues notified by the Contractor. (

Purpose:

The clause aims to outline the conditions under which the Contractor may use the Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material for the Works. It is not obligatory for the Contractor to use these resources, but they may be included as optional items in the tender to potentially reduce costs.

Implications:

The Contractor should be cautious when agreeing to use the Employer’s Equipment, as the Contract may transfer responsibility for the equipment to the Contractor upon handover.

Primary Aspects:

• Optional inclusion in the tender
• Detailed specifications in tender documentation
• Responsibility for inspection and potential risks

Expert Opinion:

Experts often recommend that Contractors thoroughly inspect the Employer’s Equipment and even create a comprehensive report, including photographic evidence, to avoid future disputes.

Relevant Illustrations:

• A Contractor was held responsible for damages to the Employer’s Equipment due to lack of proper inspection.
• A case where the Employer failed to provide Free-Issue Material on time, leading to project delays.

Interaction with Other Clauses

The clause interacts closely with tender documentation clauses, specifications, and clauses outlining the Contractor’s responsibilities. It may also relate to clauses dealing with dispute resolution in case of equipment failure or material defects.

Key Points to Consider

1. Optional Inclusion: Assess whether it’s beneficial to use the Employer’s resources.
2. Inspection: Conduct thorough inspections and document the state of the equipment.
3. Notification: Promptly inform the Engineer of any defects or shortages.
4. Risk Assessment: Evaluate the risks associated with using the Employer’s Equipment.

Real-World Instances and Case Studies

1. Construction of a Dam: In a project involving the construction of a dam, the Employer might provide specialized drilling equipment. Clause 4.20 would govern the terms under which this equipment is used, maintained, and returned.
2. Airport Construction: In an airport construction project, the Employer might provide high-precision measuring instruments. The Contractor would be responsible for these instruments as per Clause 4.20 while they are in use.
3. Railway Project: In a railway construction project, the Employer might provide specialized rail-laying machinery. The Contractor would need to inspect this machinery and report any defects, as stipulated in Clause 4.20.
4. Renewable Energy Plant: In a wind farm project, the Employer might provide turbine blades as free-issue materials. The Contractor would be responsible for inspecting these blades and reporting any defects or shortages.
5. Highway Construction: In a highway project, the Employer might provide asphalt mixing plants. The Contractor would be responsible for operating these plants and would be liable for any damages occurring during their operation.
6. Project Documentation Review: A review of past projects that involved Clause 4.20 revealed specific instances where the Employer provided specialized drilling equipment for a tunneling project. The Contractor faced challenges with the maintenance of this equipment due to a lack of spare parts. This led to project delays and subsequent claims for extensions of time and additional costs. The case highlighted the importance of clear communication and contingency planning when relying on Employer-provided equipment.
7. Legal Precedents: In a particular arbitration case, a dispute arose between the Employer and the Contractor regarding the condition of free-issue materials provided for a bridge construction project. The materials were found to be substandard, leading to structural issues. The arbitration panel, referencing Clause 4.20, ruled in favor of the Contractor, emphasizing the Employer’s responsibility to provide materials that conform to the specifications.
8. Industry Insights: Consultations with industry professionals revealed a case where the Employer provided outdated machinery for a road construction project under Clause 4.20. The Contractor had to invest in training personnel to operate this machinery, leading to additional costs. The case underscores the importance of ensuring that the Employer’s equipment is up-to-date and aligns with the Contractor’s capabilities.
9. Trade Association Case Study: A trade association documented a case where a Contractor was provided with free-issue materials for a dam construction project. The materials were delivered late, and some were damaged during transit. Relying on Clause 4.20, the Contractor raised claims for the additional costs incurred due to the late and damaged delivery. The case emphasized the need for proper documentation and timely communication between the parties.
10. Practical Insights from a Project Engineer: In a highway expansion project, the Employer provided specialized asphalt laying equipment. However, the equipment frequently broke down, causing significant project delays. The Contractor and the Employer, referencing Clause 4.20, reached an amicable resolution where the Employer compensated the Contractor for the delays and provided additional support for equipment maintenance.

Key Takeaways

• Clause 4.20 is crucial for defining the responsibilities concerning Employer-provided equipment and materials.
• The Contractor is responsible for the equipment and materials once they take possession of them.
• Both parties must adhere to the terms specified in the Employer’s Requirements.

Suggested Next Steps

• For Employers: Clearly specify the details of the equipment and materials in the Employer’s Requirements.
• For Contractors: Conduct thorough inspections of the provided equipment and materials and report any issues promptly.

Interaction with Other Clauses:

1. Management and Tracking: A robust system should be established for the management and tracking of the employer’s equipment and free-issue material. This ensures accountability and minimizes the risk of losses or damages. Regular communication and coordination between the parties involved are paramount to ensure a smooth implementation of this clause.
2. Financial Implications: The financial aspects of Clause 4.20 need to be considered. This includes the cost of maintaining, repairing, or replacing the equipment and materials provided by the Employer. A dedicated budget should be allocated for these purposes. Moreover, any claims or adjustments arising from delays, defects, or shortages should be meticulously documented and assessed for their cost implications.
3. Training and Supervision: It’s essential to provide adequate training and supervision to the Contractor’s personnel handling the employer’s equipment and free-issue material. Proper training ensures that the equipment and materials are used correctly and efficiently, thereby minimizing the risk of accidents, damages, or project delays.
4. Compliance and Ethics: Adherence to the contractual obligations outlined in Clause 4.20 is crucial. This includes the responsible use, maintenance, and return of the employer’s equipment and materials. Upholding these obligations is vital to maintain ethical practices and foster a transparent and trustworthy working relationship between the Employer and the Contractor.
5. Interplay with Other Clauses: Clause 4.20 may interact with other clauses that deal with project delays, claims, and adjustments. For instance, if the Employer’s equipment is not provided on time or is defective, it could lead to project delays, which might be addressed in other clauses related to project timelines and extensions. Similarly, the responsibilities and liabilities associated with the use of the Employer’s equipment might be referenced in clauses dealing with insurance, indemnities, and liabilities.

Main Points:

1. Clear Definition of Responsibilities: It’s imperative to clearly define the responsibilities and obligations of both the Employer and the Contractor concerning the provision, use, maintenance, and return of equipment and materials. This encompasses timelines, quality standards, and contingency plans for potential delays or shortages to mitigate potential claims or adjustments.
2. Regular Communication and Documentation: Maintain consistent communication and documentation between the Employer and the Contractor to ensure transparency and accountability regarding the provision and use of equipment and materials. Both parties should keep accurate records detailing the condition of the items, any identified defects or shortages, and any necessary repairs or replacements.
3. Cost Management: Proper management of costs associated with the provision of free-issue materials and equipment is vital. This includes accurate budgeting to account for additional costs such as storage, handling, maintenance, and repairs. It’s essential to monitor these expenses diligently and ensure that the contractual agreement aligns with the available financial resources.
4. Employee Training and Communication: The responsibilities and expectations related to the provision and use of free-issue materials and equipment should be lucidly communicated to the relevant employees involved in the execution of the Works. Providing the necessary training and support is crucial to ensure compliance with the contractual obligations and uphold quality standards.
5. Uphold Ethical Standards: Ethical standards should be maintained throughout the process. This ensures fairness, transparency, and equal treatment of all parties involved in the provision, use, maintenance, and return of equipment and materials. A clear procedure should be established to address any potential conflicts of interest or ethical concerns that may arise in relation to Clause 4.20.

Sample Letters

NOTICE OF LATE OR DEFECTIVE OWNER-FURNISHED EQUIPMENT OR MATERIALS

Date: [Insert Date]

Addressee: [Recipient’s Name and Address]

Re: Late Deliveries of Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material

Dear [Name of Designated Representative],

We are continuing to experience serious problems with the delivery of owner-furnished equipment and materials. Specifically, [Identify equipment or material items] were received at least [insert days or weeks] later than the date set out in the equipment delivery schedule. In some cases, equipment or their essential components were received as late as [insert weeks or months] after the specified delivery date. Further, due to misfabrications or other manufacturing problems, installation of this owner-furnished equipment has been much more difficult and, in some cases, impossible without substantial field modifications.

The above factors have resulted in additional costs for our field and engineering personnel and have delayed completion of the work. We may incur increased costs due to delay, disruption, rescheduling, acceleration, overtime, overmanning, stacking of trades, dilution of supervision, and other impacts. As soon as we are able to determine the extent of the delay and the costs of addressing these ongoing problems, we will request a change order for additional compensation and an appropriate time extension.

We assure you that we will do everything we can to minimize those costs and the necessary contract time extension. If we can be of any help in expediting the resolution of the problem, and getting us all back on track, please let us know.

Your cooperation in minimizing this impact will be appreciated.

Sincerely,

[Name of Project Manager]

[Name of Company]

Notification of Delay in Employer’s Equipment Delivery

[Your Company’s Letterhead]

[Date]
[Employer’s Name]
[Employer’s Address]

Subject: Delay in Delivery of Employer’s Equipment as per Clause 4.20

Dear [Employer’s Designated Representative],

We regret to inform you that we are experiencing delays in the delivery of the Employer’s Equipment, as outlined in Clause 4.20 of our contract. The equipment was expected to be delivered by [Date], but we have yet to receive it.

As a result, we anticipate that this delay will affect the project timeline and may incur additional costs. We kindly request your immediate attention to resolve this issue.

Please confirm the new delivery date and any other corrective actions you intend to take.

Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Position]

Reporting Defects in Free-Issue Material

[Your Company’s Letterhead]

[Date]
[Employer’s Name]
[Employer’s Address]

Subject: Reporting Defects in Free-Issue Material as per Clause 4.20

Dear [Employer’s Designated Representative],

Upon visual inspection of the Free-Issue Material provided under Clause 4.20, we have identified the following defects: [List defects].

As per the contract, we kindly request immediate rectification of these issues to avoid any delays or additional costs to the project.

We look forward to your prompt response.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Position]

Checklists

Checklist for Proficient Deployment
and Supervision of "Clause 4.20 Employer's Equipment and Free-Issue Material":

No.	Task	Description	Responsible Party	Status
1.	Equipment/Material Specification	Ensure that the equipment or materials to be provided by the Employer are clearly specified in the contract.	Employer & Contractor	[ ]
2.	Inspection Upon Delivery	Inspect the equipment/materials upon delivery to ensure they match the contract specifications and are in good condition.	Contractor	[ ]
3.	Documentation	Maintain proper documentation for the receipt, use, maintenance, and return of the equipment/materials.	Contractor	[ ]
4.	Training	Provide necessary training to personnel who will operate or handle the Employer’s equipment/materials.	Contractor	[ ]
5.	Maintenance Schedule	Establish a regular maintenance schedule for the equipment to ensure its optimal performance.	Contractor	[ ]
6.	Reporting Discrepancies	Report any discrepancies, defects, or shortages in the equipment/materials to the Employer promptly.	Contractor	[ ]
7.	Safe Storage	Ensure safe storage conditions for the free-issue materials to prevent damage or theft.	Contractor	[ ]
8.	Return of Equipment	Ensure timely return of the equipment to the Employer upon completion of its use, in the condition it was received (accounting for normal wear and tear).	Contractor	[ ]
9.	Claims & Adjustments	Address any claims or adjustments arising from delays, defects, or shortages in the provision of equipment/materials.	Employer & Contractor	[ ]
10.	Review & Feedback	After the project’s completion, review the process and gather feedback to improve future collaborations.	Employer & Contractor	[ ]

Checklist for Proficient Execution of [Clause 4.20]:

No.	Task	Description	Responsible Party	Status
1.	Equipment Specification	Ensure equipment/materials are clearly defined in the contract.	Employer	[ ]
2.	Delivery Inspection	Check equipment/materials upon arrival for quality and specifications.	Contractor	[ ]
3.	Equipment Handling	Ensure proper handling to prevent damages.	Contractor	[ ]
4.	Usage Documentation	Document the usage and condition of equipment/materials.	Contractor	[ ]
5.	Maintenance	Regularly maintain equipment to ensure optimal performance.	Contractor	[ ]

 

Checklist for Deployment and Supervision of [Clause 4.20]:

No.	Task	Description	Responsible Party	Status
1.	Training	Train personnel on the use and maintenance of equipment/materials.	Contractor	[ ]
2.	Safe Storage	Ensure materials are stored safely to prevent damage or theft.	Contractor	[ ]
3.	Reporting Issues	Report any defects or issues promptly.	Contractor	[ ]
4.	Return Protocol	Establish a protocol for returning equipment post-use.	Contractor	[ ]
5.	Feedback Mechanism	Set up a system for feedback on equipment/material usage.	Employer & Contractor	[ ]

 

Checklist for Applying and Overseeing [Clause 4.20]:

No.	Task	Description	Responsible Party	Status
1.	Contract Review	Regularly review the contract to ensure compliance with [CLAUSE].	Employer & Contractor	[ ]
2.	Monitoring	Monitor the use and condition of equipment/materials.	Employer	[ ]
3.	Dispute Resolution	Address any disputes related to equipment/material provision.	Employer & Contractor	[ ]
4.	Documentation Review	Periodically review all related documentation for accuracy.	Contractor	[ ]
5.	Audit	Conduct audits to ensure adherence to [CLAUSE].	Employer	[ ]

Checklist 1: Proficient Execution of Clause 4.20

Task	Responsible Party	Deadline	Notes
Review Clause 4.20 in Contract	Legal Team	Week 1	Ensure understanding of terms and conditions
Inventory of Employer’s Equipment	Contractor	Week 2	List all equipment provided by the Employer
Inspection of Employer’s Equipment	Contractor	Week 2	Document condition, take photos
Inventory of Free-Issue Material	Contractor	Week 3	List all materials provided by the Employer
Inspection of Free-Issue Material	Contractor	Week 3	Check for defects, shortages
Notify Employer of Defects	Contractor	Week 4	Use formal communication channels
Confirm Insurance Coverage	Contractor	Week 4	Ensure coverage for using Employer’s Equipment

---

Checklist 2: Deployment and Supervision of Clause 4.20

Task	Responsible Party	Deadline	Notes
Schedule Equipment Use	Project Manager	Week 5	Align with project timeline
Train Personnel	Contractor	Week 5	Ensure safe and effective use of Employer’s Equipment
Deploy Free-Issue Material	Contractor	Week 6	Use as per project requirements
Monitor Equipment Condition	Contractor	Ongoing	Regular checks to avoid breakdowns
Report Any Issues	Contractor	Ongoing	Immediate reporting to avoid delays

---

Monitoring Execution of Clause 4.20

Task	Responsible Party	Deadline	Notes
Weekly Equipment Inspection	Contractor	Weekly	Check for wear and tear
Material Usage Tracking	Contractor	Weekly	Ensure optimal use of Free-Issue Material
Update Employer	Contractor	Bi-weekly	Status updates on equipment and material usage
Review Insurance Coverage	Contractor	Monthly	Confirm ongoing coverage
Final Report	Contractor	Project End	Document condition of returned equipment

Flowcharts

Flowchart Explanation:

The flowchart visually represents the process and steps associated with the application of [CLAUSE] and its relationship to other clauses:

1. Start: The process begins when the Employer decides to provide equipment or materials to the Contractor.
2. Equipment/Material Specification: The next decision point is to determine if the equipment or materials to be provided are specified in the contract.
   • Yes: If specified, the Employer provides the equipment or materials.
   • No: If not specified, there’s a need to negotiate the terms between the Employer and the Contractor.
3. Contractor’s Use: Once the equipment or materials are provided, the Contractor uses them for the execution of the Works.
4. Regular Inspections and Maintenance: During the use of the equipment or materials, regular inspections and maintenance are carried out to ensure they remain in good condition.
5. Return of Equipment/Material: After the completion of the Works or once the equipment or materials are no longer needed, they are returned to the Employer.
6. End: The process concludes upon project completion.
7. Interaction with Other Clauses: This branch represents how [CLAUSE] interacts with other clauses in the contract. It can lead to:
   • Claims & Adjustments: Addressing any claims or adjustments arising from delays, defects, or shortages in the provision of equipment/materials.
   • Project Delays: Handling project delays that might be caused due to issues with the equipment or materials.
   • Insurance & Liabilities: Dealing with insurance and liabilities related to the use, maintenance, and return of the equipment or materials.

Flowchart Explanation

1. Start: The flowchart begins with the initiation of the project where the Employer has Equipment or Material that could be used by the Contractor.

2. Employer has Equipment or Material:

   • This is the point where the Employer decides whether to make specific equipment or materials available for the Contractor’s use.

3. Optional Bill Items in Tender & Details in Tender Documentation:

   • These are the two paths that can be taken based on the Employer’s decision.
   • The Employer can include the potential use of these items as optional bill items in the tender to possibly reduce the Tender Price.
   • Alternatively, the Employer can provide details, arrangements, and prices of the Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material in the tender documentation.

4. Lower Tender Price & Must Meet Specifications:

   • If optional bill items are included, it could lead to a lower Tender Price.
   • The Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material must meet the specifications outlined in the tender documentation.

5. Contractor’s Responsibility:

   • Regardless of the path taken, the Contractor has certain responsibilities, such as inspecting the Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material.

6. Inspect Equipment & Report & Photographic Record:

   • The Contractor is advised to inspect the equipment thoroughly and possibly create a detailed report, including photographs, of the equipment’s condition.

7. Risk of Hidden Faults:

   • Even after taking all precautions, there’s always a risk of latent defects in the Employer’s Equipment.

8. Free-Issue Material:

   • This is where the Employer provides Free-Issue Material as per the contract.

9. Provided by Employer & Contractor Collects:

   • The Employer can either provide these materials at a specified time and place or the Contractor may have to collect them from a specified location.

10. Inspect & Notify Engineer:

    • The Contractor is required to visually inspect the Free-Issue Material and notify the Engineer of any defects or shortages.

11. Employer Rectifies Issues:

    • The Employer is obligated to rectify any issues that the Contractor reports.

12. End:

    • This is the conclusion of the process outlined in Clause 4.20.

The flowchart serves as a visual guide to understand the various steps, decisions, and responsibilities involved in Clause 4.20. It helps in grasping the complexities and interactions between the Employer and the Contractor concerning the Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Clause 4.20: Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material

1. What is the purpose of Clause 4.20?

Answer: The clause outlines the conditions and responsibilities for the Contractor to use the Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material. It provides options but does not make it obligatory for the Contractor to use these resources.

---

2. Is it mandatory for the Contractor to use the Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material?

Answer: No, it’s not mandatory. The use of these items may be included as optional bill items in the tender to potentially reduce costs.

---

3. Who is responsible for the Employer’s Equipment?

Answer: While the Employer is generally responsible for the equipment, the Contractor becomes responsible for each item while it’s being operated, driven, or controlled by the Contractor’s personnel.

---

4. What happens if the Employer’s Equipment is unavailable?

Answer: The Contractor may be entitled to an extension of time and delay costs under Sub-Clause 8.4(e) if the Employer’s Equipment is unavailable.

---

5. Are there any inspection requirements for the Contractor?

Answer: Yes, the Contractor is advised to thoroughly inspect the Employer’s Equipment and Free-Issue Material. It’s often recommended to create a detailed report, possibly including photographs, of the equipment’s condition.

---

6. What should the Contractor do if they find any defects or shortages in the Free-Issue Material?

Answer: The Contractor is required to visually inspect the Free-Issue Material and promptly notify the Engineer of any defects or shortages. The Employer is obligated to rectify these promptly.

---

7. Who bears the cost and risk for the Free-Issue Material?

Answer: The Employer is obligated to supply the Free-Issue Material free of charge, at his own risk and cost.

---

8. Can the Contractor collect the Free-Issue Material from a location outside the Site?

Answer: Yes, the Particular Conditions might state that the Contractor should collect the Free-Issue Material from a location not necessarily within the Site.

---

9. Is the Employer’s Equipment considered as Plant?

Answer: No, the Employer’s Equipment is excluded from the definition of Plant, and the Contract requirements in respect of Plant do not impose obligations on the Employer’s Equipment.

---

10. What are the payment terms for using the Employer’s Equipment?

Answer: The Contractor may be charged for the use of Employer’s Equipment as per Sub-Clauses 2.5 [Employer’s Claims] and 3.5 [Determinations].