Views in the last 30 days: 208
Estimated read time: 12 minute(s)
- When you must notify
- What the Engineer must do
- How claims are calculated
- When and how theyāre determined
Connected claims process. The tie-in with Clause 20.2 ensures contractors know exactly how to make a claim and what timelines apply.
- A clear description of the condition (e.g., unexpected rock, debris, groundwater)
- Why itās āunforeseeableā (support with bore logs, reports, tender drawings)
- How it may affect your progress and/or cost
Your notice isnāt just a courtesy; itās a contractual lifeline. It triggers site visits, instructions, and maybe variations. If itās late, vague, or missing, your claim might be rejected before itās even reviewed. Protect your rights: treat this notice as the critical first step.
Direct engagement helps avoid disputes later. Like a referee watching the play, the Engineerās presence ensures any call is based on facts, not paperwork or guesswork.
That flexibility is a lifesaver on fast-track jobs. Small surprises stay small, and you avoid a domino effect of delays.
Always treat Clause 4.12 as your first step, but remember: Clause 20.2 is the critical bridge to actual time or money.
Especially on big, complex jobs, this grown-up approach keeps everyone honestāand helps prevent disputes down the road.
Solution: Train field engineers to escalate unknown conditions immediatelyāeven before knowing the full cost impact.
Solution: Use the Base Date and all tender documentation to benchmark foreseeability. Even better, propose a Geotechnical Baseline Report (GBR) to define whatās expectedāand whatās notāupfront.
Contract | Approach |
---|---|
FIDIC Yellow 2017 | Structured, detailed, and fair; emphasizes prompt notice and risk balance |
NEC4 ECC | More collaborative but less precise about āunforeseenā |
AIA A201 | Addresses concealed conditions but relies heavily on U.S. case law |
FAR (U.S. Govāt) | āDiffering Site Conditionsā clause (Type I/II) is robust but process can be very formalistic |
Risk Item | Description | Party Responsible | Comments / Basis |
---|---|---|---|
Subsurface Conditions | Soil type, rock layers, groundwater | Employer (except unforeseeable) | Contractor relies on site data per Clause 4.10. Unforeseeable issues may trigger 4.12. |
Contamination / Hazardous Materials | Asbestos, oil, heavy metals | Employer | Unless Contractor contributed or it was obvious during tender site visit. |
Utility Locations (Known) | Water, gas, power (per utility surveys) | Employer | Data expected from Employer. Contractor can rely on its accuracy. |
Utility Locations (Unknown) | Buried/unmapped services | Shared | Typically unforeseeable; subject to 4.12 if not reasonably discoverable. |
Archaeological Finds | Ruins, artifacts, fossils | Employer | Treated under Clause 4.23. Work may be suspended. |
Weather / Climatic Conditions | Rainfall, temperature extremes | Contractor | Considered foreseeable unless truly exceptional (Clause 18 ā Exceptional Events). |
Traffic / Access Restrictions | Limited road use, load limits | Employer | Especially if restrictions are due to local regulations unknown at tender. |
Site Access / Rights of Way | Land acquisition delays, 3rd-party access | Employer | Clause 2.1 obligates Employer to provide access. |
Existing Structures | Integrity of nearby buildings | Shared | Contractor protects; Employer must disclose known risks. |
Site Topography | Slopes, flood risk, erosion | Contractor | Generally observable and thus foreseeable. |
UXO (Unexploded Ordnance) | Landmines, shells, military waste | Employer | Unforeseeable and high-risk. May be Exceptional Event. |
Groundwater Behavior | Seepage, seasonal variation | Shared | Some foreseeable; deep aquifers may qualify for 4.12. |
ā Clause 4.12 Compliance & Risk Management Checklist
š Pre-Construction / Tender Stage

š§ Site Conditions Monitoring (During Construction)

š¢ Notice Procedure ā Clause 4.12.1

šµļøāāļø Engineerās Investigation ā Clause 4.12.2

š Engineerās Instructions ā Clause 4.12.3

š Claim Filing (Clause 4.12.4 + Clause 20.2)

āļø Engineerās Determination ā Clause 4.12.5

š Records & Documentation

Contractor finds unexpected natural or man-made site conditions (e.g., hidden sub-surface structures, odd groundwater).
Prompt written notice to Engineer starts the process and documents the conditions.
Contractor details the conditions for the Engineerās inspection and for any future claims.
Contractor keeps working, using best methods to manage the situation, showing project commitment.
Contractor follows any instructions given in response to the conditions.
If instructions change the scope significantly, Clause 13 (Variations) applies.
If not a variation, work continues as originally planned, incorporating minor adjustments.
Contractor may claim extra time/payment (per Sub-Clause 20.1), if justified by the unforeseen conditions.
Engineer reviews the reported conditions and impact on the project.
Engineer decides what was truly unforeseeable and the impact on entitlements.
Engineer adjusts contract value/payment, considering both difficult and favorable conditions for fairness.
Once everythingās evaluated, the process closes and the project continues.
Dear [Engineerās Name],
Pursuant to Sub-Clause 4.12.1 of the Conditions of Contract, we hereby notify you that we have encountered physical conditions at the Site which we consider to be Unforeseeable.
Details of Conditions:
On [insert date], during excavation at [location], we encountered [e.g., a dense basalt rock layer at 2.5 meters depth], which differs materially from the site investigation reports provided at Tender stage.
Why Unforeseeable:
These conditions were not identified in the geotechnical reports made available prior to the Base Date and could not have been reasonably anticipated by an experienced contractor exercising due diligence.
Impacts:
- Additional excavation time and equipment
- Disruption to our construction schedule
- Increased costs
Yours faithfully,
[Name]
[Position]
[Contractorās Company Name]
Dear [Contractorās Name],
Following your Notice dated [insert date] regarding the unforeseen physical conditions at [location], we confirm that we have inspected the Site in accordance with Sub-Clause 4.12.2.
Based on our investigation, we determine the condition is considered Unforeseeable and falls within the scope of Sub-Clause 4.12. Accordingly, you are instructed to proceed as follows (per Sub-Clause 13.3.1 [Variation]):
[Instruction, e.g., Excavate using rock breakers and dispose material off-site]
[Any temporary support measures]
[Updated sequencing to accommodate delay]
Please proceed accordingly and record all associated impacts to cost and progress for evaluation under Clause 20.2.
Yours sincerely,
[Engineerās Name]
[Title]
[Employer or Consultantās Company Name]
Dear [Engineerās Name],
Further to our Notice dated [insert date] and your instruction dated [insert date] regarding the Unforeseeable Physical Conditions at [location], we hereby submit our formal Claim for:
- Extension of Time under Sub-Clause 8.5
- Payment of Cost per Sub-Clauses 4.12.4 and 20.2.1
- Description of the events and physical conditions encountered
- Justification of why the conditions were unforeseeable
- Photographic and documentary evidence
- Impact on program and revised critical path
- Breakdown of additional costs (equipment, labor, disposal, etc.)
Should you require additional details or site clarifications, please let us know.
Yours faithfully,
[Name]
[Position]
[Contractorās Company Name]