Purpose of Clause 12.1
The main objective of Clause 12.1 Procedure for Tests after Completion is to establish the framework for Tests after Completion. It outlines who is responsible for what, when these tests are to be carried out, and how the results should be interpreted. These tests are pivotal for confirming that the Works meet the project requirements.
Implications of Clause 12.1 Procedure for Tests after Completion
Employer’s Responsibilities: The Employer must provide all necessary resources for the Tests after Completion, unless otherwise stated in the Particular Conditions.
Notice Period: The Employer must give the Contractor 21 days’ notice of the date after which the Tests after Completion will be carried out.
Contractor’s Absence: If the Contractor is not present, the test will proceed and the Contractor will have to accept the results.
Test Results: Both parties are responsible for compiling and evaluating the test results, considering any prior use of the Works by the Employer.
Primary Aspects of Clause 12.1 Procedure for Tests after Completion
Test Resources: Includes electricity, equipment, fuel, instruments, labor, and materials.
Timing: Outlines when the tests should ideally occur.
Notice: Details the notice required for scheduling the tests.
Evaluation: Discusses how test results should be evaluated and considered.
Expert Opinion
Experts generally view this clause as a safeguard for both parties. It ensures that the Works are up to the project’s standards and gives a structured approach to testing and evaluation.
Key Points to Keep in Mind for Clause 12.1 Procedure for Tests after Completion
Advance Preparation: Make sure all necessary resources for the Tests after Completion are identified and ready well in advance.
Notice Period: Be aware of the 21-day notice period for scheduling the Tests after Completion. Mark your calendars accordingly.
Compliance with Manuals: Ensure that the Tests after Completion are in line with the Operation and Maintenance Manuals provided under Clause 5.7.
Contractor’s Presence: The Contractor should make it a point to be present during the Tests after Completion to avoid any uncontested results.
Evaluation of Results: Both parties should be involved in the evaluation of the test results and take into account the Employer’s prior use of the Works.
Documentation: Keep all test results and evaluations well-documented for any future references or in case of disputes.
Timelines: Adhere strictly to the timelines set for the tests to avoid complications or potential penalties.
Dispute Resolution: In case of disagreements regarding the test outcomes, be prepared to invoke Clause 3.5 Determinations or Clause 20.1 Claims.
Interaction with Other Clauses
Clause 5.7 Operation and Maintenance Manuals
- Connection with Clause 12.1: The Tests after Completion are to be conducted following the Operation and Maintenance Manuals provided by the Contractor.
- Why It Matters: This is crucial because adherence to these manuals ensures that the tests are conducted in a standardized manner, thereby reducing the scope for disputes.
Clause 8.7 Delay Damages
- Connection with Clause 12.1: Delays in conducting the Tests after Completion could potentially lead to delay damages.
- Why It Matters: This establishes a financial incentive for both parties to adhere to the timeline for Tests after Completion, as outlined in the contract.
Clause 11.9 Performance Certificate
- Connection with Clause 12.1: The issuance of the Performance Certificate generally signals the Employer’s takeover of the Works or Section, thus triggering the need for Tests after Completion.
- Why It Matters: The Performance Certificate is often considered the green light for the initiation of post-completion tests, making its issuance a key milestone.
Clause 11.10 Unfulfilled Obligations
- Connection with Clause 12.1: Both clauses deal with responsibilities that extend beyond the project’s completion but serve different purposes.
- Why It Matters: While Clause 11.10 covers any unfulfilled obligations, Clause 12.1 specifies the Tests after Completion. Understanding the nuances between these two can help in better contract management.
Clause 20.1 Claims
- Connection with Clause 12.1: Disputes or disagreements arising from Tests after Completion could lead to claims under this clause.
- Why It Matters: This clause serves as a legal avenue for both parties to settle any disputes that might arise during the implementation or interpretation of Clause 12.1.
Clause 3.5 Determinations
- Connection with Clause 12.1: If there are disagreements or disputes about the results of the Tests after Completion, this clause may be invoked to make formal determinations.
- Why It Matters: Clause 3.5 serves as an adjudicative mechanism to resolve ambiguities or disagreements, ensuring a smoother project flow.
Flowchart
Detailed Explanation of the Flowchart
Start: Project Completion: The flowchart begins at the point where the project is considered complete.
Performance Certificate Issued?: This decision point checks whether the Performance Certificate has been issued, which is often a prerequisite for initiating Tests After Completion.
Initiate Tests After Completion: If the Performance Certificate is issued, the Tests After Completion are initiated.
Conduct Tests as per Operation and Maintenance Manuals: The tests are conducted according to the guidelines set in the Operation and Maintenance Manuals.
Tests Successful?: This decision point checks the success of the tests.
- Yes: If the tests are successful, the process moves to Final Acceptance.
- No: If the tests are not successful, it checks whether Delay Damages are applicable.
Delay Damages Applicable?: This decision point checks if delay damages are applicable.
- Yes: If applicable, Clause 8.7 is invoked for delay damages.
- No: The tests are reconducted.
Proceed to Final Acceptance: If the tests are successful, the process moves towards final acceptance.
Unfulfilled Obligations?: This decision point checks for any unfulfilled obligations.
- Yes: If there are unfulfilled obligations, Clause 11.10 is invoked.
- No: The process ends.
End: The flowchart ends here.
Case Studies
Case Study 1: Delayed Test Resources
Scenario: A Contractor completed a water treatment facility in North United States. The Employer was responsible for providing the necessary resources for the Tests after Completion as per Clause 12.1. However, the Employer failed to provide the resources on time.
Outcome: Due to the delay, the Contractor invoked Clause 8.7 Delay Damages and Clause 20.1 Claims for compensation. The Employer had to pay delay damages as they did not adhere to the responsibilities laid out in Clause 12.1.
Learning: This case emphasizes the importance of both parties being fully aware of their responsibilities as outlined in the clause and the repercussions of not adhering to them.
Case Study 2: Non-Compliance with Manuals
Scenario: The Employer proceeded to conduct Tests after Completion for a road construction project but did not follow the Operation and Maintenance Manuals provided by the Contractor under Clause 5.7.
Outcome: The tests failed, and the Employer blamed the Contractor for the failure. However, upon investigation, it was found that the Employer did not adhere to the guidelines in the manuals. As a result, Clause 3.5 Determinations was invoked, and it was determined that the Employer was at fault.
Learning: Compliance with the manuals is crucial as per Clause 12.1, and failure to do so can lead to false test outcomes and potential disputes.
Case Study 3: Absence of Contractor
Scenario: The Employer gave 21 days’ notice for the Tests after Completion of a wind farm. The Contractor did not attend the tests, assuming their absence would invalidate them.
Outcome: According to Clause 12.1, the Employer proceeded with the tests, and the Contractor had to accept the results, which turned out unfavorable for them.
Learning: The Contractor’s presence during the Tests after Completion is strongly advised, as their absence does not invalidate the tests but rather puts them at a disadvantage.
Sample Letters
Sample Letter 1: Employer Notifying Contractor of Test Date
[Your Company’s Letterhead]
[Date]
[Contractor’s Address]
Subject: Notice of Tests after Completion as per Clause 12.1
Dear [Contractor’s Name],
As stipulated under Clause 12.1 of our contract, we are required to give 21 days’ notice prior to conducting Tests after Completion. We hereby inform you that these tests are scheduled to take place on [Test Date].
We expect your team to be present for these tests as per the clause’s guidelines.
Please confirm your attendance by [Confirmation Deadline].
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Position]
Sample Letter 2: Contractor Requesting Compliance with Manuals
[Your Company’s Letterhead]
[Date]
[Employer’s Address]
Subject: Compliance with Operation and Maintenance Manuals for Tests after Completion – Clause 12.1
Dear [Employer’s Name],
We would like to remind you that the upcoming Tests after Completion should be carried out in strict compliance with the Operation and Maintenance Manuals provided under Clause 5.7.
Failure to adhere to these guidelines may result in inaccurate test results, leading to unnecessary disputes.
We appreciate your cooperation.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Position]
Sample Letter 3: Contractor Acknowledging Test Results
[Your Company’s Letterhead]
[Date]
[Employer’s Address]
Subject: Acknowledgment of Test Results as per Clause 12.1
Dear [Employer’s Name],
We acknowledge the receipt of the test results conducted on [Test Date]. As per Clause 12.1, we accept these results and look forward to the next steps in our contractual obligations.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Position]
Checklists
Checklist 1: Proficient Execution and Deployment of Clause 12.1
| Task | Responsible Party | Deadline | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Confirm necessary resources for tests | Employer | [Date] | [ ] |
| Provide 21-day notice for tests | Employer | [Date] | [ ] |
| Confirm attendance for tests | Contractor | [Date] | [ ] |
| Conduct tests | Employer | [Date] | [ ] |
| Evaluate test results | Both Parties | [Date] | [ ] |
Checklist 2: Assist in Applying and Overseeing Clause 12.1
| Task | Responsible Party | Deadline | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Review Operation and Maintenance Manuals | Contractor | [Date] | [ ] |
| Confirm test methodology | Employer | [Date] | [ ] |
| Document test results | Both Parties | [Date] | [ ] |
| Resolve any disputes | Both Parties | [Date] | [ ] |
Checklist 3: Guide and Monitor the Execution of Clause 12.1
| Task | Responsible Party | Deadline | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Confirm test date | Contractor | [Date] | [ ] |
| Ensure resources are ready | Employer | [Date] | [ ] |
| Perform tests | Employer | [Date] | [ ] |
| Validate test results | Contractor | [Date] | [ ] |
| Finalize test report | Both Parties | [Date] | [ ] |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the purpose of Clause 12.1?
- The purpose is to outline the procedure for Tests after Completion, detailing responsibilities of both the Employer and the Contractor.
Who is responsible for providing resources for the tests?
- Unless otherwise stated in the Particular Conditions, the Employer is responsible for providing all necessary resources.
What happens if the Contractor is not present during the tests?
- The tests will proceed and the Contractor will have to accept the results as accurate.
How are the test results evaluated?
- Both parties are responsible for compiling and evaluating the test results.
Is there a timeline for conducting these tests?
- The tests should be carried out as soon as reasonably practicable after the Works or Section have been taken over by the Employer.
Common Misunderstandings
Resource Provision: A common misunderstanding is that the Contractor is responsible for providing the resources for the tests. Unless otherwise stated, it is the Employer’s responsibility.
Notice Period: Some may assume that a 21-day notice is not mandatory. However, according to the clause, the Employer must give a 21-day notice for the tests.
Test Results: Another misconception is that the Contractor has the sole responsibility for evaluating test results. In reality, both parties are involved in the process.
Contractor’s Absence: Some Contractors think their absence will invalidate the tests, but according to the clause, the tests will proceed and the Contractor must accept the results.
Related posts:
Understanding Clause 12.4: Failure to Pass Tests after Completion in FIDIC Yellow Book 1999
FIDIC Clause 6.1: Engagement of Staff and Labour
Understanding FIDIC Clause 6.9: Ensuring Qualified and Ethical Contractor’s Personnel
Understanding Clause 17.1 Indemnities in FIDIC Yellow Book
Powered by YARPP.
